Patent opinions from the Eastern District of Texas and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

Weekly Digest
E.D. Tex.

Vision advancement LLC v. Johnson & Johnson Vision Care Inc, No. 2:05-cv-00455 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2007)

Claims Construed
Court
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division
Case No.
No. 2:05-cv-00455, Dkt. No. 140
Decided
January 26, 2007
Judge
John D. Love, M.J. — Tyler
Document
Order
Docket Entry
MEMORANDUM AND OPINION AND ORDER - The court issues this claim construction opinion and order to construe terms that the parties contend are either in dispute or otherwise require contruction. For the foregoing reasons, the Court interprets…
Length
29 pages

Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140_ Filed 01/26/07 Page 1 of 29 PagelD #:

<pagelD>

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS

MARSHALL DIVISION

VISION ADVANCEMENT, LLC § §

Plaintiff §

§ CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:05¢v455

VS. §

8

VISTAKON, A DIVISION OF §

JOHNSON & JOHNSON VISION §

CARE, INC. § §

Defendant §

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Figure on page 1 of the opinion

The Court issues this claim construction opinion and order to construe terms that the parties

contend are either in dispute or otherwise require construction.

The plaintiff, Vision Advancement, LLC (“Vision Advancement”), claims that defendant

Vistakon (“Vistakon”) infringes over ninety claims in the seven patents-in-suit, U.S. Patents No.

4,898,461 (“the ‘461 patent”), No. 5,657,108 (“the ‘108 patent”), No. 5,877,839 (“the ‘839 patent”),

No. 6,186,625 (“the ‘625 patent”), No. 5,270,744 (“the ‘744 patent”), No. 6,527,389 (“the ‘389

patent”), No 5,166,711 (“the ‘711 patent”), and No. 6,409,340 (“the ‘340 patent”).

The parties identified terms from those claims that they contend are either in dispute or that

otherwise require construction. The parties filed claim construction briefs and the court held a

Markman hearing. For the reasons set forth below, the Court construes the identified claims in

accordance with the rulings made in this opinion.

The Patents-In-Suit

The inventor of each of the patents-in-suit is Dr. Valdemar Portney (“Portney”). All of the

patents-in-suit stem from the same original 1987 patent application, Ser. No. 56,050 (the ‘0502 Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140_ Filed 01/26/07 Page 2 of 29 PagelD #:

Figure on page 2 of the opinion

<pagelD>

Appin.”). The ‘461 patent was filed as a continuation of the ‘050 Appln. and each of the other

patents-in-suit depend from a divisional application of the application that resulted in the ‘461

patent. Accordingly, each of the patents-in-suit have essentially the same specification, including

the same drawings. Therefore, just as the parties have done in their briefs, references to the

specification for the ‘461 patent are used interchangeably for each of the other patents.

The patents-in-suit (collectively referred to as the “Portney Patents”) relate to multifocal

ophthalmic lenses (e.g., intra-ocular lenses, contact lenses, and corneal lenses), The lens is

multifocal to correct for different distances. One example of a multifocal lens is the bifocal which

corrects for near and distant vision. Vision correction is accomplished by different curvature of the

lens. The ‘461 patent states that, “The present invention provides an improved multifocal

ophthalmic lens by combining (a) a series of alternating power zones with (b) a continuously varying

power within each zone, as well as in transition from one zone to another. In other words, a plurality

of concentric zones (at least two) are provided in which the variation from far to near vision

correction is continuous, i.e., from near correction focal power to far correction focal power, then

back to near, and again back to far, or vice versa.” ‘461 patent, at 2:35-44.

Applicable Law

“It is a ‘bedrock principle’ of patent law that ‘the claims of a patent define the invention to

which the patentee is entitled the right to exclude.” Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 1303, 1312

(Fed. Cir. 2005) (en banc) (quoting Innova/Pure Water Inc. v. Safari Water Filtration Sys., Inc., 381

F.3d 1111, 1115 (Fed. Cir. 2004)). In claim construction, courts examine the patent’s intrinsic

evidence to define the patented invention’s scope. See id.; C_R. Bard, Inc. v. U.S. Surgical Corp.,

388 F.3d 858, 861 (Fed. Cir. 2004); Bell Atl. Network Servs., Inc. vy. Covad Communications Group,3 Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 _ Filed 01/26/07 Page 3 of 29 PagelD #:

Figure on page 3 of the opinion

<pagelD> |

Inc., 262 F.3d 1258, 1267 (Fed. Cir. 2001). This intrinsic evidence includes the claims themselves,

the specification, and the prosecution history. See Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1314; CR. Bard, Inc., 388

F.3d at 861. Courts give claim terms their ordinary and accustomed meaning as understood by one

of ordinary skill in the art at the time of the invention in the context of the entire patent. Phillips,

415 F.3d at 1312-13; Alloc, Inc. v. Int’l Trade Comm’n, 342 F.3d 1361, 1368 (Fed. Cir. 2003). |

The claims themselves provide substantial guidance in determining the meaning of particular

claim terms. Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1314. First, a term’s context in the asserted claim can be very

instructive. Jd. Other asserted or unasserted claims can also aid in determining the claim’s meaning

because claim terms are typically used consistently throughout the patent. /d. Differences among

the claim terms can also assist in understanding a term’s meaning. /d. For example, when a

dependent claim adds a limitation to an independent claim, it is presumed that the independent claim

does not include the limitation. /d. at 1314-15.

Claims “must be read in view of the specification, of which they are a part.” Jd. (quoting

Markman v. Westview Instruments, Inc., 52 F.3d 967, 978 (Fed. Cir. 1995)). “[T]he specification

‘is always highly relevant to the claim construction analysis. Usually, itis dispositive; it is the single

best guide to the meaning of a disputed term.’” Jd. (quoting Vitronics Corp. v. Conceptronic, Inc.,

90 F.3d 1576, 1582 (Fed. Cir. 1996)); Teleflex, Inc. v. Ficosa N. Am. Corp., 299 F.3d 1313, 1325

(Fed. Cir. 2002). This is true because a patentee may define his own terms, give a claim term a

different meaning than the term would otherwise possess, or disclaim or disavow the claim scope.

Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1316. In these situations, the inventor’s lexicography governs. Id. Also, the

specification may resolve ambiguous claim terms “where the ordinary and accustomed meaning of

the words used in the claims lack sufficient clarity to permit the scope of the claim to be ascertained4 Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 Filed 01/26/07 Page 4 of 29 PagelD #:

Figure on page 4 of the opinion

<pagelD>

from the words alone.” Teleflex, Inc., 299 F.3d at 1325. But, “although the specification may aid

the court in interpreting the meaning of disputed claim language, particular embodiments and

examples appearing in the specification will not generally be read into the claims.” Comark

Communications, Inc. v. Harris Corp., 156 F.3d 1182, 1187 (Fed. Cir. 1998); see also Phillips, 415

F.3d at 1323. The prosecution history is another tool to supply the proper context for claim

construction because a patent applicant may also define a term in prosecuting the patent. Home

Diagnostics, Inc., v. Lifescan, Inc., 381 F.3d 1352, 1356 (Fed. Cir. 2004) (“As in the case of the

specification, a patent applicant may define a term in prosecuting a patent.”’).

Although extrinsic evidence can be useful, it is “less significant than the intrinsic record in

determining ‘the legally operative meaning of claim language.’” Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1317 (quoting

C.R. Bard, Inc., 388 F.3d at 862). Technical dictionaries and treatises may help a court understand

the underlying technology and the manner in which one skilled in the art might use claim terms.

However, technical dictionaries and treatises may provide definitions that are too broad or may not

be indicative of how the term is used in the patent. Jd, at 1318. Similarly, expert testimony may aid

a court in understanding the underlying technology and determining the particular meaning of a term

in the pertinent field, but an expert’s conclusory, unsupported assertions as to a term’s definition are

entirely unhelpful to a court. Jd. Generally, extrinsic evidence is “less reliable than the patent and

its prosecution history in determining how to read claim terms.” /d.

The patents-in-suit also contain “means-plus-function” limitations that require construction.

Where a claim limitation is expressed in “means-plus-function” language and does not recite definite

structure in support of its function, the limitation is subject to 35 U.S.C. § 1 12, 46. Braun Med., Inc.

y. Abbott Labs., 124 F.3d 1419, 1424 (Fed. Cir. 1997). In relevant part, 35 U.S.C. § 112, | 65 Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 _ Filed 01/26/07 Page 5 of 29 PagelD #:

Figure on page 5 of the opinion

<pagelD>

mandates that “such a claim limitation ‘be construed to cover the corresponding structure...

described in the specification and equivalents thereof.’” Jd. (citing 35 U.S.C. § 112, 6).

Accordingly, when faced with means-plus-function limitations, courts “must turn to the written

description of the patent to find the structure that corresponds to the means recited in the

[limitations].” Jd.

Construing a means-plus-function limitation involves multiple inquiries. “The first step in

construing [a means-plus-function] limitation is a determination of the function of the means-plus-

function limitation.” Medtronic, Inc. v. Advanced Cardiovascular Sys., Inc., 248 F.3d 1303, 1311

(Fed. Cir, 2001). Once a court has determined the limitation’s function, “the next step is to

determine the corresponding structure disclosed in the specification and equivalents thereof.” Jd.

A “structure disclosed in the specification is ‘corresponding’ structure only if the specification or

prosecution history clearly links or associates that structure to the function recited in the claim.” Jd.

Moreover, the focus of the “corresponding structure” inquiry is not merely whether a structure is

capable of performing the recited function, but rather whether the corresponding structure is “clearly

linked or associated with the [recited] function.” Id.

The Terms

Terms with Agreed Constructions

The Court adopts the parties’ construction of several previously disputed terms. Those terms

and their agreed constructions are:

Ophthalmic Lens: The phrase “ophthalmic lens” is to be given its plain and ordinary

meaning, e.g., lens for the eye, intra-ocular lenses (IOLS), contact lenses, and corneal implant and

only lenses.

Figure on page 6 of the opinion

6Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 Filed 01/26/07 Page 6 of 29 PagelD #:

<pagelD>

Concentric: The term “concentric” is to be given its plain and ordinary meaning, e.g., having

a common center or center point.

phrase “transition regions” is to be given its plain and ordinary Transition Regions: The

meaning, e.g., segments of multifocal lens that change from a first vision correction power to a

second vision correction power.

Terms that Both Parties Assert Require Construction

The Court will construe the following disputed terms which the parties agree require

construction: (1) “Vision Correction Power/Vision Correction Value”; (2)

(3) “Zones”; (4) “Annular”, (5) “Optical Axis”; (6) “means for “Progressive/Progressively”;

providing in each of said first and second zones a first region having a first vision correction power

and a second region having a second vision correction power which is significantly different from

vision correction power between the first and second optical said first vision correction power, the

(7) “means for providing on one of said anterior or posterior faces, powers being progressive”; and

axis, a generally repetitive pattern comprising a number of concentrically relative to said optical

radially outwardly alternating, annular regions or [sic] high and low vision correction powers, said

regions of high and low vision correction powers being interconnected in an optical sense by

regions having a range of progressive intermediate vision transition regions, each of said transition

powers between the high and low vision correction powers.” correction

The Court will also construe, as appropriate, the following terms which Vistakon asserts need

construction, while Vision Advancement claims these terms do not need to be construed: (8) whether

the preambles of certain claims should be construed as limitations, (9) “each cycle of such

continuous variation from one value to the other and then back to the first”; (10) “correction power

Figure on page 7 of the opinion

7Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 Filed 01/26/07 Page 7 of 29 PagelD #:

<pagelD>

being caused to vary”; (11) “continuously”; (12) “intermediate vision correction power”; “high

vision correction power’; “low vision correction power”; “near vision correction power’; “far vision

correction power”; and “predetermined vision correction power”; and (13) “said regions of high and

low vision correction powers being interconnected in an optical sense by transition regions.”

1, Vision Correction Power/Vision Correction Value

The parties agree that the claims of the Portney Patents variously refer to the terms “vision

correction power” or “vision correction value” synonymously. Those terms are found in Claims 1,

10(b), 14, 15, 19, 28, 29, 30, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36 and 41-44 of the ‘461 patent; Claims 1 and 8 of the

“108 patent; Claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10, 12, 13, 14, 17 and 18 oft he ‘839 patent; Claims 1, 3, 4, 5,

7, 10, 13, 16 and 17 of the ‘625 patent; Claims 1, 2,3, 5, and 8 of the ‘744 patent; Claims 1, 4, 7 and

14 of the ‘389 patent; 1, 4, 9 and 10 of the ‘711 patent; and Claims 1, 3, 5 and 10 of the ‘340 patent.

Vision Advancement argues that the common and ordinary meanings of “Vision Correction

Power/Vision Correction Value” should prevail and cites to two medical dictionaries to propose a

construction of “The measure of magnification required or used to neutralize a harmful or

undesirable condition or to improve the condition of a person’s eye sight.” Vistakon advances the

construction of “The dioptric power or value needed in a lens prescription to correct a refractive

error; the dioptric power of the lens is measured with the lens off-eye.”

the Markman hearing, Vision Advancement agreed to the following alteration of At

construction, “The dioptric power or value in a lens to correct refractive error.” Defendant’s

However, Vision Advancement maintains that Vistakon’s construction further requiring that the lens

lens off-eye” is too limiting because it is not needed to define the term. be “measured with the

claims that the Portney Patents’ only reference to vision correction power is to the power Vistakon

Figure on page 8 of the opinion

8Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 _ Filed 01/26/07 Page 8 of 29 PagelD #:

<pagelD>

of a lens measured off-eye and that there is no mention in the patents of determining the power of

the lens on-eye. Because, Vistakon argues, Portney never suggested to the examiner that the power

of the lens—his or prior art lenses-should be determined on-eye, it stands to reason that the power

of a lens should be measured off-eye. While it is true that the prosecution history can inform the

Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1317, the Court is not willing to import what meaning of claim language, see

was not mentioned in the patent or prosecution history. There is no statement that the power of the

lens must be measured off-eye. Nor will the Court import that limitation into the claims because

there is no statement that the lens can be measured on-eye. See Omega Eng’s, Inc. v. Raytek Corp.,

334 F.3d 1314, 1326 (Fed. Cir. 2003) (opining that for prosecution disclaimer to arise, the alleged

“disavowing actions or statements made during prosecution [must] be both clear and unmistakable”).

Therefore, the Court construes “Vision correction power/value” to mean the “The dioptric

power or value in a lens to correct refractive error.”

2. Progressive/Progressively

The terms progressive/progressively are found in Claims 1, 10(b), 14(b), 19, 28, 29, 30, 32,

1 and 8 oft he ‘108 patent; Claims 3, 4, 5, 9, 10, 12, 14, 17 35, 36 and 44 of the ‘461 patent; Claims

5, 7, 10, 13, 16 and 17 oft he ‘625 patent; Claims | and 8 and 18 of the ‘839 patent; Claims 1, 3, 4,

14 of the ‘389 patent; Claims 1, 4, 9 and 10 of the ‘711 patent; of the ‘744 patent; Claims 1, 4, 7 and

and Claims 1, 3, 5 and 10 of the ‘340 patent.

Vision Advancement asserts that the term “progressive/progressively” should be construed

as “continuous change or continuously changing,” while Vistakon submits “A controlled, gradual

gradient designed to provide a certain vision correction power, without any abrupt changes or edges

or breaks or transitions.”

Figure on page 9 of the opinion

9‘Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140_ Filed 01/26/07 Page 9 of 29 PagelD #:

<pagelD>

Turning first to the claims, claim 1 of the ‘461 patent states that “the correction power being

caused to vary continuously and progressively.” ‘461 patent, 7:50-51. Vision Advancement’s

“progressively” superfluous because the claim language already definition would appear to make

requires that the power “vary continuously”, which is the same as “continuously changing.” See

Inc., 395 F.3d 1364, 1372 (Fed. Cir. 2005) (“A claim Merck & Co. v. Teva Pharms. USA,

construction that gives meaning to all the terms of the claim is preferred over one that does not do

supports a construction of “progressive” different than that so.”). Therefore, the claim language

urged by Vision Advancement.

The specification of the Portney Patents describes “progressive” when discussing the nature

of the change in power in the lens of the invention. As the specification states, “This change is

continuous (progressive), without any abrupt correction changes, or “edges.” ‘461 patent, 2:44-45;

see also ‘461 patent Abstract. Vision Advancement points to that language as showing that the ‘461

patent defines “progressive” as continuous. However, that would require the Court to ignore the rest

preceding sentence, the specification appears to define of that sentence. Additionally, in the

continuous when it states that the variation of the vision correction of the invention “is continuous,

i.c., from near correction focal power to far correction focal power, then back to near, and again back

to far, or vice versa.” ‘461 patent, 2:40-44. The term “progressive” appears in the next sentence

or variation also be “without any abrupt correction along with the requirement that the change

changes, or edges.”

disclosed in the Portney Patents to demonstrate how Furthermore, the only embodiment

vision correction power was adjusted by the curvature of the lens surface, depicted a lens surface that

gradually transitioned between high and low vision correction powers, through intermediate vision

Figure on page 10 of the opinion

10Col. 4:16-17; Col. 5:48-6:40. The fact that the Portney Patents disclose that correction powers. See

“The undulating surface of the lens is preferably formed by a computer-controlled machining

apparatus” underscores the gradual nature of the undulating surface. See Col. 5:48-6:40.

The statements and arguments made by the patentee to distinguish the prior art further

support that the term “progressive” requires a gradual change or gradient of vision correction power

changes or edges. In the Background section of the specification, the without any abrupt correction

U.S. Patent No. 4,162,122 (“Cohen”) because the lens disclosed there had patentee distinguished “disadvantages due to... abrupt curvature change of the lens surface from one zone to another.”

Consistent with that statement, during prosecution of the °461 patent Portney ‘261 patent, 2:3-13.

distinguished the prior art Cohen and DeCarle bifocal lenses as lacking “any true progressive

correction powers between the bifocal regions.” Prosecution History, Def Br., Ex. P., VIST029127

(also noting “no suggestion that DeCarle’s polishing is done to provide true progressive intermediate

correction powers between the purely bifocal zones”). Portney further argued that his “pro gressive

multifocal ophthalmic lens tends to reduce or eliminate this shadow image [of the prior art]” and

“provides progressive intermediate imaging.” Jd.

gradient of vision correction power should also be defined as Vistakon urges that the

and that the vision correction power should be “certain”. However, the Court finds no

basis to add those terms to the definition of “progressive/progressively.” Both of those terms appear

to add ambiguity to the definition. For example, what does it mean to be “controlled” or “certain”?

The specification of the ‘461 patent refers to the lens as preferably being formed by a “computer-

require it be so formed. ‘461 patent, 5:48-49. Therefore, the controlled” apparatus, but it does not

Court declines to add those terms to the definition of “progressive/progressively.”

Figure on page 11 of the opinion

11construes the terms “progressive/progressively” to mean “A gradual Accordingly, the Court

gradient of vision correction power without any abrupt correction changes or edges.”

3. Zone

The term “zone” is found in Claims 1, 5, 10(a), 20, 21, 22, 23, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 35, 36, 37,

38 and 41-44 of the ‘461 patent; Claim 12 of the ‘744 patent; and Claims 9 and 10 of the ‘711 patent.

Vision Advancement contends that the term “zone” should be given its plain and ordinary

“One or more regions distinguished from adjacent parts by meaning and proposes a construction of

Vistakon, on the other hand, proposes a construction of “A a distinctive feature or characteristic.”

complete cycle, such as from the intermediate power through the high power, then back through the

intermediate power to the low power, and finally back to the intermediate power.”

Portney’s various references to “zone” in the “961 patent Vision Advancement argues that

show that he did not act as his own lexicographer and define the term narrowly as proposed by

Vistakon. Vision Advancement first points to the repeated descriptions of the prior art as having

zones, even though none of those prior art references disclose a “complete cycle” of powers as

proposed by Vistakon. See, e.g., Col. 1:25-33; 1:34-41; 2:3-7; 2:16-20. Vision Advancement also

points to other uses of zone in the specification that do not refer to a complete cycle: (1) “the radial

> 3 he radial width of the zone for near-to-far D 2 +

4 BELEAERA BAR eet Me OF ke ed ~ &

transition”, 2:45-50, and (2) “the small centrally placed “zone” of a constant curvature.” 5:13-14.

Finally, Vision Advancement argues that Vistakon’s narrow definition of zone is inconsistent with

the use of that term in the other claims, such as claim 19.

Vistakon argues that the inventor expressly defined zone in the specification as “a zone is

considered to include a complete cycle, i.e., from the intermediate power through the high power,

1]

Figure on page 12 of the opinion

12Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 Filed 01/26/07 Page 12 of 29 PagelD

low power, and finally back to the intermediate then back through the intermediate power to the

power.” See Col. 5:15-19. Vistakon contends that the reference to the centrally placed zone was

merely Portney defining an exception to its definition of zone. Finally, Vistakon argues that its

definition is “compatible” with the use of “zone” in claim 19.

The Court agrees with Vision Advancement that “zone” is not limited to a complete cycle.

the “461 patent to refer to various optical As noted by Vision Advancement, “zone” is used in

cycle. The Court turns first to the claims. In each regions, many of which do not refer to a complete

self defines what is required of the zone with claims in which “zone” appears, the claim it of the

respect to vision correction power or value. Claim 1 does require a complete cycle in a zone. Claim

1 states that “each cycle of such continuous variation from one value to the other and then back to

being repeated in a plurality of zones.” However, independent claims 10, 19, and 36 do not the first

19 refers to “each of said zones having a first such a cycle for a zone. For example, claim require

th far vision correction power and an correction power, a second region wi region with near

intermediate vision region between the first and second regions. . .” Claim 19 does not require that

the zone include a full cycle of power, which for claim 19 would require the power return to the near

dditional requirement that a zone must have vision correction power. The Court will not add the a

. claims expressly provide for what power variation is

claimed (e.g., near to far in claim 19).

As pointed out by Vision Advancement, “zone” is used in the specification to refer to areas

have a complete cycle. Vistakon relies that have a complete cycle as well as areas that do not

he patentee acted as his own lexicographer description at Col. 5:15-19 to argue that t primarily on the

in defining “zone.” The Court disagrees. The patentee’s use of zone does not demonstrate that he13 expressly defined “zone” as a complete cycle. As discussed above, the patentee used “zone” to refer

Figure on page 13 of the opinion

to less than a complete cycle in many places in the specification and the claims. Additionally, the

language relied on by Vistakon is a description of a preferred embodiment and is specifically in

5:5-19. Without clear indicia that the patentee defined zone to include a reference to Figure 4.

complete cycle, the Court will not impose that description of a preferred embodiment onto the

See Tex. Instruments, Inc. v. Int’l Trade Comm'n, 805 F.2d 1558, 1563 (Fed. meaning of “zone.”

Cir. 1986).

Vistakon further argues that there is no explanation in the patent of what a “distinctive feature

Vision Advancement proposes. The Court agrees that the Vision or characteristic” would be as

Advancement’s construction of zone as “regions distinguished from adjacent parts by a distinctive

feature or characteristic” is unnecessarily vague. As discussed above, “zone” refers to areas having

certain optical characteristics such as variations in power. Thus, the Court construes “zone” as “One

or more areas distinguished by optical characteristics.”

4. Annular

The term “annular” is found in Claims 5, 10(a), 14(b), 22, 32, 35, 38 and 44 of the ‘461

patent; Claims 4, 5, 9, 11, 14, 15 and 18 of the ‘839 patent; patent; Claims 1, 2, 8 and 9 of the ‘108

9,13, 14 and 17 of the ‘625 patent; Claim 1 of the ‘744 patent; Claims 4, 9 and 15 of

‘711 patent; and Claims 1, 3,5, 10 and 11 of the ‘340 patent. the ‘389 patent; 1, 2, 4, 9 and 10 of the

Vision Advancement argues that “annular” should be construed as “ring-shaped,” while

Vistakon argues for a construction of “forming a ring.” Vision Advancement, in the alternative,

agrees to the same dictionary definition that Vistakon relies on with an exception. Vision

Advancement disagrees with Vistakon’s construction to the extent that it does not include the14 Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140 Filed 01/26/07 Page 14 of 29 PagelD

Figure on page 14 of the opinion

complete dictionary definition, i.e., “ofr elating to, or forming a ring.” Merriam-Webster’s Medical

Desk Dictionary Revised Edition at 41.

The Court agrees with the parties and finds that “annular” has not been given a special

definition in the patent and, therefore, looks to the dictionary definition proffered by the parties to

supply the necessary construction. See Philips, 415 F.3d at 1322 (finding dictionaries or comparable

sources useful and appropriate when used to assist in understanding the commonly understood

Thus, the Court construes “annular” to mean “of, relating to, or forming aring.” meaning of words).

5. Optical Axis

The term “optical axis” is found in Claims 10(a), 14(a) and 14(b) of the ‘461 patent. Vision —

Advancement initially advanced a construction of the term “optical axis” as “A straight line

perpendicular to the front of the lends and extending through the center of the pupil.” Vistakon first

proposed, “The straight line normal to both faces of a lens along whose path a ray will pass without

being deflected.”

At the Markman hearing, the parties agreed with the Court’s proposed construction. Thus,

the Court construes “optical axis” to be “A straight line perpendicular to the front of the lens and

extending straight through the lens without being deflected.”

IMLEGJIOSP FTO viding in eack OF Said } rst ana S€COnNa ZONES A fl

cy second region having a second visio1n correction power" which is correction powers and a significantly different from said first vision correction power, the vision correction power between the first and second optical powers being progressive.

The parties agree that this limitation, found in Claim 10 of the ‘461 Patent, is in means-plus-

parties agree that the function is “providing in each of said first and function form. Similarly, both

second zones a first region having a first vision correction power and a second region having a15 second vision correction power which is significantly different from said first vision correction

Figure on page 15 of the opinion

power...” The only disagreement between the parties as to the function is Vistakon’s inclusion of

the phrase, “the vision correction power between the first and second optical powers being

progressive.”

The Court finds that the function proposed by Vistakon is exactly as recited in the claim

language. See Col. 8:33-35 ( “the vision correction power between the first and second optical

powers being progressive”). Because this language is directly from the claim language describing

the function, the Court concludes that it should be included as part of the construed function. See

Lockheed Martin Corp. v. Space Sys./Loral, Inc., 249 F.3d 1314, 1324 (Fed. Cir. 2001), vacated and

remanded on other grounds, 535 U.S. 1109 (2002).

The parties also substantially agree that the corresponding structures are the only two

structures disclosed in the Portney Patents for carrying out the recited functions. Both parties agree

are disclosed for providing variable vision correction to the following recitation, “Two structures

power. The first structure is an undulating lens posterior surface that has a continuously changing

curvature...” At this point, Vistakon proposes the inclusion of the phrase “. . . and which provides

the recited vision correction powers.” Similarly, the parties agree to the following recitation for the

second structure: “The second structure is a

having refractive material indices which continuously vary in the lens radial direction (out from the

optical axis)...” Again, Vistakon then proposes the inclusion of the phrase, “. .. and which provide

the recited vision correction powers as required by the function.”

Vision Advancement argues and Vistakon concedes that its proposed language is not found

ever, Vistakon argues that the whole point of the in the claim language or in the specification. How

Figure on page 16 of the opinion

16of the invention disclosed in the Portney Patents is that the “means plus function” limitation and

undulating surface or the changing refractive indices of the surface of the lens provides the recited

vision correction powers. Def.’s Br. at 24.

The Court agrees with Vision Advancement that Vistakon’s proposed additional language

(“and which provide the recited vision correction powers required by the function’) is nowhere

found in the intrinsic record. Further, the Court agrees with Vision Advancement that the additional

structure and, in fact, is encompassed within the function proposed language is not part of the

discussed above.

Accordingly, the Court construes the above means-plus-function element as:

limitation to be construed under 35 U.S.C. 3 112, 4 6, A means-plus-function wherein the function is providing in each of said first and second zones a first region having a first vision correction power and a second region having a second vision correction power which is significantly different from said first vision correction power, the vision correction power between the first and second optical powers being

are disclosed for providing variable vision correction progressive. Two structures power. The first structure is an undulating lens posterior surface that has a continuously changing curvature. The second structure is a lens having non-homogeneous surface characteristics having refractive material indices which

radial direction (out from the optical axis). The term continuously vary in the lens includes these structures and equivalents thereof.

anterior or posterior faces, concentrically relative to 7. Means for providing on one of said

said optical axis, a generally repetitive pattern comprising a number of radially outwardly alternating, annular regions or [sic] high and low vision correction powers, said regions of high and low vision correction powers being interconnected in an optical sense by transition regions, each of said transition regions having a range of progressive intermediate vision correction powers between the high and low vision correction powers.

Again, the parties agree that this limitation, found in Claim 14 of the ‘461 Patent, is in

means-plus-function form. Similarly, both parties agree that the function is “providing on one of the

anterior or posterior faces, concentrically relative to the optical axis, a generally repetitive pattern17 comprising a number of radially outwardly alternating, annular regions of high and low vision

Figure on page 17 of the opinion

correction powers...” The only disagreement between the parties as to the function is Vistakon’s

inclusion of the phrase, “said regions of high and low vision correction power being interconnected

in an optical sense by transition regions, each of said transition regions having a range of pro gressive

intermediate vision correction powers between the high and low vision correction powers.”

The Court finds that the function as proposed by Vistakon is exactly as recited in the claim

language. See Col. 8:56-61 (“said regions of high and low vision correction power being

interconnected in an optical sense by transition regions, each of said transition regions having a range

of progressive intermediate vision correction powers between the high and low vision correction

powers”). Because this language is directly from the claim language describing the function, the

Court concludes that it should be included as part of the function. See Lockheed Martin, 249 F.3d

at 1324.

The parties also substantially agree, as discussed above, that the corresponding structures are

the only two structures disclosed in the Portney Patents for carrying out the recited functions. As

before, both parties agree to the following recitation, “Two structures are disclosed for carrying out

undulating lens posterior surface that has a continuously this function. The first structure is an

the inclusion of the phrase“... and

which provides the recited vision correction powers.” Similarly, the parties agree to the following

recitation for the second structure: “The second structure is a lens having non-homogeneous surface

characteristics having refractive material indices which continuously vary in the lens radial direction

(out from the optical axis)...” Again, Vistakon then proposes the inclusion of the phrase, “... and

which provide the recited vision correction powers as required by the function.”

Figure on page 18 of the opinion

18As with the other means-plus-function element, Vision Advancement argues and Vistakon

is not found in the claim language or in the specification. concedes that its proposed language

whole point of the “means-plus-function” clause and of the However, Vistakon argues that the

invention disclosed in the Portney Patents is that the undulating surface or the changing refractive

indices of the surface of the lens provides the recited vision correction powers. Def.’s Br. at 24.

Court agrees with Vision Advancement that Vistakon’s As previously discussed, the

proposed additional language (“and which provide the recited vision correction powers required by

the function”) is nowhere found in the intrinsic record. Further, the Court agrees with Vision

Advancement that the additional proposed language is not part of the structure and, in fact, is

encompassed within the function discussed above.

Accordingly, the Court construes this means-plus-function element as:

A means-plus-function limitation to be construed under 35 U.S.C. § 112, 4 6, wherein the function is providing on one of the anterior or posterior faces,

optical axis, a generally repetitive pattern comprising concentrically relative to the a number of radially outwardly alternating, annular regions of high and low vision correction powers, said regions of high and low vision correction power being interconnected in an optical sense by transition regions, each of said transition regions having a range of progressive intermediate vision correction powers between the high and low vision correction powers. ‘'wo structures are disclosed for providing variable vision correction power. The first structure is an undulating lens posterior surface that has a continuously changing curvature. The second structure is a lens having non-homogeneous surface characteristics having refractive material

in the lens radial direction (out from the optical indices which continuously vary axis). The term includes these structures and equivalents thereof.

Terms that Vistakon Asserts Require Construction

8. Preambles

An additional claim construction issue is whether the preamble of the independent claims

asserted by Vision Advancement are limitations on the scope of the claims. Vistakon argues that the19 preambles of the following claims should be construed as limitations: claims 1, 10, 14, 19, 35, 36

Figure on page 19 of the opinion

and 44 of the ‘461 Patent; claims 1 and 8 of the ‘108 Patent; claims 1, 4, 7, 14 and 18 of the ‘839

Patent; claims 13 and 17 of the ‘625 Patent; claim 1 of the ‘744 Patent; claims 7 and 14 of the ‘389

and 9 of the ‘711 Patent; and claims 5 and 10 of the ‘340 Patent. Patent; claims 1, 4

essential structure or steps, or if it is ‘necessary to give life, meaning, If a preamble “recites

it is a limitation.” Poly-America, LP. v. GSE Lining Te ch, Inc., 383 and vitality’ to the claim, then

F.3d 1303, 1309 (Fed. Cir. 2004) (quoting Pitney Bowes, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 182 F.3d

1298, 1305 (Fed. Cir. 1999)). On the other hand, “i]t is well settled that if the body of the claim sets

out the complete invention, and the preamble is not necessary to give life, meaning and vitality to

the claim, then the preamble is of no significance to claim construction because it cannot be said to

constitute or explain a claim limitation.” Altiris Inc. v. Symantec Corp., 318 F.3d 1363, 1371 (Fed.

Computer Sys., Inc., 308 F.3d 1304, 1310, 64 USPQ2d 1832, Cir. 2003), (quoting Schumer v. Lab.

1837 (Fed. Cir. 2002)).

Vistakon that the preamble is a limitation in each of the apparatus or The Court agrees with

structural claims identified by Vistakon, i.e., ‘461 patent, claims 1, 10, 14 19, 32, 35,36 and 44; ‘108

patent, claims 1 and 8; ‘839 patent, claims 7, 14 and 18; ‘625 patent, claims 7, 13 and 17; ‘340

patent, claims 5 an uC So

claims 1, 4 and 9. In each of those claims, the Court finds that the preamble recites structure

necessary to give meaning to the claims. In each of these claims, the body of the claim specifically

refers to elements or structures contained in the preamble, e.g., ‘461 patent, claim 1 - “the correction

power,” and ‘108 patent, claim 1 - “said lens.” Therefore, the preamble necessarily gives meaning

to the rest of the claim.

Figure on page 20 of the opinion

20the preambles of claims 1 and 4 are limitations of those claims. The Court does not agree that

Each of those claims are method claims. Those preambles indicate the purpose (vision correction)

not add meaning to the claimed methods. For example, even of the claimed methods, but they do

if the preamble merely recited “a method,” the body of the claim has the same meaning. Therefore,

the Court does not construe the preambles in those claims to be limitations.

9. Each cycle of such continuous variation from one value to the other and then back to the

first

of the ‘461 patent. Vision Advancement argues that The above phrase is found in Claim 1

the phrase does not require construction because its plain meaning is understood by one of ordinary

skill in the art.

Vistakon argues that although the plain language of this phrase does not indicate that the first

correction value and that the second correction value must each be the same in each zone, the

examiner allowed this claim “with the understanding that the first correction values should be the

same and the second correction values should be the same.” Vistakon contends that the examiner

rejected a claim that included the language: “all of said regions of hi gh optical powers not

necessarily having a uniform width or a uniform high optical power, and all of said regions of low

optical powers not necessarily having a uniform width or a uniform low optical power,” as “new

matter” because “nowhere is it disclosed that these high and low powers can be anything different”

and only issued the amended claim as Claim 17 in the ‘461 Patent after Portney amended it to

remove the objectionable language. According to Vistakon, the Examiner issued claim 17 of the

‘461 patent only after the objectionable language was removed and with the understanding that the

“high” and “low” optical powers in the different regions of the Portney lens were the same.

Figure on page 21 of the opinion

21The Court disagrees with Vistakon’s reliance on the prosecution history. As an initial matter,

the Court declines to speculate on the Examiner’s “understanding” beyond what is stated in the

record, Vistakon’s argument relies on the meaning of the statement that “[n] owhere is it disclosed

that these high and low powers can be anything different.” Does that mean, as Vistakon urges, that

Court finds that the Examiner’s comments are the powers must be the same in each zone? The

unclear as to what “anything different” refers. The preceding sentencing in the prosecution history

refers to various features related to the high and low powers in each zone, e.g., a transition from high

to low and the “high and low powers [are] defined as those powers to correct for near vision and

distant vision.” “Anything different” might refer to the relationship of the powers, just as described,

lly, the argument raised by Vistakon relates to rather than the powers being the same. Additiona

appears. Therefore, this does not amount to an claim 17, not claim 1 where the language at issue

express or unequivocal disclaimer as Vistakon suggests. Middleton, Inc. v. Minn. Mining & Mgf.

Co., 311 F.3d 1384, 1388 (Fed. Cir. 2002).

Vistakon acknowledges that the plain language of this phrase does not indicate that the

Because the Court concludes that the prosecution correction values must be the same in each zone.

se, the Court finds that no construction is_ history does not change the plain meaning of that phra

necessary.

10. Correction power being caused to vary

This phrase is found in Claim 1 of the ‘461 patent. Vistakon urges a construction of, “the

power varies due to the design of the surface of the lens.” Vision Advancement contends dioptric

ued and that this phrase does not require any that “vision correction power” has already been constr

gues that the term should not be limited to the further construction. Further, Vision Advancement ar

2]

Figure on page 22 of the opinion

22“designof” the lens, nor should it reference the physical structure of the “surface” of the lens, as

Court finds nothing in that phrase or the specification correction power is an optical property. The

cited by Vistakon that would require inserting the “design of the surface of the lens” into that phrase.

Accordingly, the Court declines to construe this phrase.

11. Continuously

that this term, found in Claim 1 of the ‘461 patent, Again, Vision Advancement argues

and does not require construction. Vistakon proposes should be given its plain and ordinary meeting

a construction of, “The lens surface has no discontinuities in progressivity.” Vistakon supports its

argument by pointing to the prosecution history and the examiner’s disallowance of claim language

allowing correction power to change “substantially continuously.” The Court disagrees with

Vistakon. The Examiner rejected the use of “substantially” because of the “inherent vagueness” of

That does not provide an explicit basis to graft that word. Vistakon’s Br., Ex. R at VIST029104.

onto the term a requirement of “no discontinuities in progressivity.” Without such a clear showing,

the Court finds no need to construe this term.

12. Intermediate vision correction power; High vision correction power; Low vision correction

Far vision correction power; and Predetermined power; Near vision correction power; vision correction power

Vistakon seeks a consiruction 0

patent, and Claim 1 of the “711 patent. However, the Court has already construed the terms “vision

correction power” and “progressive” and finds that these terms sufficiently convey to the jury all that

is necessary to understand these additional terms. The Court sees no need to construe the terms

further to add terms of relativity or specific distance. Thus, the Court concludes no further

construction is necessary.

Figure on page 23 of the opinion

23Case 2:05-cv-00455-LED-JDL Document140- Filed 01/26/07 Page 23 of 29 PagelD

of high and low vision correction powers being interconnected in an optical 13. Said regions

sense by transition regions

Vistakon seeks construction of is “said regions of high and low vision The final phrase

interconnected in an optical sense by transition regions” from claim 14 of correction powers being

the ‘461 patent. Vision Advancement once again contends that “vision correction power” has

and the parties have agreed on the proper construction for “transition already been construed,

according to Vision Advancement, this phrase does not require any further regions.” Therefore,

construction. Vistakon, on the other hand, posits that the term should be construed as, “the regions

of high and low vision correction powers are connected by a transition region in a fashion to provide

usable vision correction.” In essence, Vistakon seeks construction of the portion of the phrase that

states “interconnected in an optical sense.” Vision Advancement does not contend that phrase has

already been construed.

Vistakon that the phrase “interconnected in an optical sense” requires The Court agrees with

construction. While the Court agrees that Vistakon’s proposed construction, for the most part, is

in an optical sense,” and supported by the portions of the ‘461 patent appropriate for “interconnected

finds the word “useable” to be vague. Therefore, the Court construes cited by Vistakon, the Court

and low vision correction powers being interconnected in an optical the term “said regions of high

mean “the regions of high and low vision correction powers are sense by transition regions” to

a transition region in a fashion to provide vision correction.” connected by

Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, the Court interprets the claim language in this case in the manner

set forth above. For case of reference, the Court’s claim interpretations are set forth in a table24 attached to this opinion.

Figure on page 24 of the opinion

So ORDERED and SIGNED this 26th day of January, 2007.

bP re fe UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE

Figure on page 25 of the opinion
25es n on on Zo isi isi

al V V M tic ar AI Op ul CL

nn A

is Ax

RM

TE ion tion rect rec Cor Cor

ue

ively Val / rogress wer ssive/P o Progre P

A o

t

he

ne T

t mO on ro fr e f h tur r ’s ful ed ug f ea o on rm uir ro o f ers ha eq th ht p r

g r ove rai o s pr or r e e st uou m o h h ed ntin e i t t hap e Co y ure

g-s ntor e meas e Rin cem e n dja h F’S i a t d f NTIF s l e o LAI en us P l ht. r ge g o NT nte ts an si t N I ce ars ch UCTIO O d pon NSTR J f an gi CO o yre r le

b o sirab

unde

ristic. a ion

e racte ndit h cha co t

f

ar o dicul a lize on D pen utra ficati OSE M . ng per ne gni ROP AI pil ndi a ma P CL u xte o n p e t tio

ndi

ed co uish sly

e tiveting uou r h tincdis ntin o t dis co

TED

SPU n DI A A f
    • o i e

ay e a h r h T es T e ac h f er, er, s t l ow ow ge s il f ng p p an ed n w o ami ch gn ve le d. or n esi s acti cte a F s. ctio d n efr S efle d te ion r orre o e r c M d ht n n ple ansit o c l tri ER

ig te a ate e ateom tr t d, s op T ss ra media medi th medic olle i di pa st nter nter inter ntr s i i co ON n . UCTI le g or; NSTR e in s rr CO n r k ge , e NT’S i y c e, d wer NDA l all ba cl e o r DEFE

n r rcy p de e we g r. fi we we ovi h on po TION n we po po or r al t pti TRUC ut o po p du scri CONS ho al a a pre r wit o gr ed o

t h asur o ck uc me t mal a s or b e gh n h ou out T g o hr s s th AR n o t t t ha ak wi h ric e H ei ose t ug re t pt u C b h ro b n wi io al w e th ai t d v

e w h r y ert en h o t o n c adi t l em a gr e ect ED h h. ho h orr POS t ot tfr t c RO a b a P p a e wer

h n s o ded

ht t sio n p ee g up vi e n hi r l | ab

A A o

, t Of he

ne T

g nt O in ro al be t f ic gh ptor ai f o str o al

ht n du ect g tion ctio a orr S rai g rrec rre gr c c RT’ est in co co ri OU h at pt C t rel e dio

mor

ne , h i o ed. ug sl t flect ro en er de th l ow t

r ges p en o as an adi e wer e are h gr ctiv o h d c fra p t n re a r f

stics. o o or acteri char

ns t e g ou l n ith or.

for . e r es on lu cula ami dg w si err va endi e y vi gerp an n dinp teno ed i TION t ext uish a TRUC ou g. ing CONS ith n dist w ri

e y h b pt s t ru n

ab e

l

Figure on page 26 of the opinion

26id sa on on on isi gi gi v re re

st fir tion rrec tly co can gnifi g g d si in ain an
av av h h a tion er rrec w co po
st nd d fir eco ent n s ffer a di nd er eco a ow s p

m on aes

    • o isi zon fr v
on isi v ond d sec en ai we s st bet fir
m c no T c b at harac n-ho h ont e eri teris moge e inuo al tics neou us

s ly ns c

e ons l true s on d eco isi nd nd v eco s
ng res vidi i uctu ro nd str p ice tly n s can
ior gnifi s i str ter e si one uctu os ar z u re ch p a nd ang er ha in ion v g rect ch w in cor a h g e ich st fir f
su e t o 3 rfa ac ren 5 ce urf ffe
i s ed di r s los wer efra disc o d U. con ctiv curv p ai S.C tinu e a atur at n s . ous e. h r m io ly len t fo fro reg

s t

s rs ha ch fi

whi

h a id av sa s in i ng d g vi n
ha a g st a din fir ovi pr

e A y b b

s) xi l n n e n a dia ch g ch on o o d d h io a hi in hi isi isi isi on on t vis r w av w v v v ec ec

h s s g d ture ed din n truc n clos on ovi a s ctio dis ecti pr

s orre e. corr y i c y ssiv ntl n d

usl r gre fica rue us a nuo o pro gni on aes i nst eneo onti f si gi on co mog es c e z . on ho id r ion ch cti ov nct hi dire e pr on r on ion fu tion w ctiv s cti o we ecti rect ch rrec fra n orre w o orr cor a co re le rs. e c p c e er

t usly we h T t d u uo po t rs f un o ntin ng fi o ( co nt vi 5

ace g ere a tion urf gin ng diff h 3 s-func e s an idi r a ns-plu id g e ch r. rov er, we mea s ov y n Th we p w po d wer pr m ar vi po po ai po o v rial ha d een n s

r ate e tw m io f n m cit be o eg s e re e r r a h i ures h f t e e truct e t st .C. h h s h h r U.S t e on- T t hic nd fi h n d d w eco t on ble: ai s

sec re ria re s s on es on vatu va a i ng d tati ic si cur t st vi n limi nd vi rs r on ha a ed s i fi fi si o ed cit al en vi st a t uir re ic l istics d r q pt acter n fi re o char a

st v di § Ae ruct isi sclo ure on sed b d 1 m y n 1 eans-p m r a 2 lus-fu o va , nction fr d d n on on al ec sec e i eri co s h mat rrec 4 t tion 6 s e ent h i nd val t s fo eco , d qui s w rue e a r n as her nst

s n io one ein co ristic eg z l s racte pr r ca n es cha ov pti le dic und idin o in ula g

ting al tic er f. po op st nd reo we r u he r. ng fi t . l ng vi th 5

s) dia vi ha e xi a ch ha 3 a r hi a

w

fun limi var n cti tati iab ers io on on e T le ow eg h le h p r T ns e .

S.C

d U. n on ctio e fi g sec ire ctiv r n m d efra s ei g er r t b n i t avi s

t y h to u ousl a o tinu ( con

Figure on page 27 of the opinion

27f y

    • o b w
    • o id l sa s cal on y rn ti s gi ar all tte op an re nul di pa me

an ra “ n f on ctio o isi r orre v s, o c xi f

on a rior ve nsiti lly nte ssi tra h a trica a gre ted g ncen pro onnec i ns co
nterc h io or i eg n r
ers i dly g ow d r war isin p n o ut mpr
a o co ns, n ion a ng
    • o a rect vidi egi cor ive ro r c] y lat p

w i rall re

    • o [s ene l g o ior n

t ter o h pos en te ac l twe edia e ca h be term pti g

in f o s, hi er d ne

    • o n wer mb ai o sio po g, nu s e vi atin s, f h ern f ce o t alt o fa
nd ve n d e d a titi io ai ns ai epe vis s se s r

| { e A , b e re , 6 y h a is

m ar T ax m ro v n ai f io ns a cl n vis o r s l egi erio

es e i eria or e r nt i lud h mat eri ctur ly a inc t ost stru on f ard

e p s ecti o tw ing r nts h d corr ou pris o vale t on i om ein d qui ec usly d c her rue e s nuo ose a ally w onst

e s onti scl tric c es ristic c n di h cen h l s racte a g y con e t ca n es cha hi rall h pti le dic ce on r ne t

  • o in fa ecti o ge ng

sur orr f . idi

c ers rov er . ow nd ior p nd eof p a ter u her g e t , er pos t . al n ctur a ing mb e n 5 n

s) di vi stru ng h nat nu iv o 3 unctio xi a ch ha s ngi t lter lat plus-f a r hi ha w a re eans-

w i c er. o o f n m es s ng w w l o o tio uctur a a lati po T e t , e nc str h du g itiv es n fu

un din pet c o e a vi re fa f h pro f o

d T o C. n s s e id S. a n n h n ular a §U.

le e T sio nn s

ion e l vi a lly is rect tiv ia d h m di frac ad i t tion er re ture. r rn sa mita t urva st tte li

c r ures pa

t sly fi ble uct 2, o u uou g ria str al 1 t

  • o ntin in va tic 1 ( co av op

h §

s in e A con refr term b tinu act i eclia d ous ive ut te n ly o a n 2,

a er 1

ow ns e [1

ace s p io tiv rs. s rf hi eg ela or { we de ng su t r r eri ng ion po ovi gi dly st di ect pr an res on f ar g o po ovi , ch dir ch uctu ecti o tw sin t pr 6 hi str corr ou pri w m at ng om d

at e h ei c n rue t eri e h t b a e o onst u al h t e h h c o T ar v t s, (v s g is g ce a a tin ion hi a ry h ula . f und ion ne

a nct o de fu rs, n er vi m e we d rei d ro o d atur po n f he un p ri d ite urv a r al o w fn in on rec c ng, be tic dic ec e corr nati um p 5 tion e es s h ect er n o e 3 s-func h et T d ion d w alt e h ns-plu t hh nd ose ai f h t mea te a or discl s lo o t

eri s, l n ost t r xi en sio p s o d a s vi fir necte w f ercon a . h int ally .C d al ich h s n n ar ntric U.S ite c ure c usly n ns io nul nce ec ptir ruct whi nuo e i o is an y co r n r oad st nti l egi v all rio ctio ia s co r di nte un on l i ra a f tati

n f s limi a a o r i s) ng o o xi re ryi t on a uctu car isi tion str v rrec

co §

s v in e A

isi term

i on ediat b

e

s). n , xi al h a r 12 a adi ic we 1 r wh ers po ive |

ow y lat or cor p all re eri g rect ly er st din ion on ard g en o po ovi , e ecti tw sin g t pr 6 h corr ou pri T ng om d

ei c n true ous b a e o ons ene h , c mog vi t es on ho ng sio ac m ecti lati enn f er dir ndu twe e t u be n

rs, e o r y p we itiv ein de t ousl ow e po pet f her un u inu er h re al o w o cont s. t g, ber ic ( ce cor atin m pt 5 on

fa rect ern nu o e 3 functi sur ion d alt e h s-plus-

ai f h t mean y h s o t des r or g clu m va eri hi s, in ro ost rn xi f n p d tte a

necte pa

i Tw d ercon a . e o n int ally S.C h s a n ular ntric U. se t e n ns nn once e h le i io a ly c or on th t eg ial eri ncti

r ad ant fu tion w n r s mita

    • o a f li l o r i s o o al en t ic l istics pt acter o char
      Figure on page 28 of the opinion

28y vary b

h id r g Sa he ch Hi ot a

E

ion d riat n an va e ctio cl on s orre y si on C c vi on gi

nsiti re f tra n m o ected f he ro rconn o t f inte n er i ow h

h p ne uc g k o s . i ac ns n h b gio a

tion re o rrec ng t co i

nd be ue a val

he al t o tic w t op o

wer l s o e uou p d st h ntin

use r t co ca fi e o ens n t s io

vis

t t t d ot ot o o no n s n s n n n n n n a hi en hi en e ee ee T e T e be d b b e b n s b n n ee on on ir o o sio gr si si qu isi i isi Vi a Vi Vi e V V r a

m e

e e re n re er uir ir uir ui o ui t q qu q eq eq y re re re r r ar

e din h or

y y t d, y , y ed. hy ny ed. n ued. n rue n ued n tru gt a tru a str a nst a nstr d a ons n ons con co co ul c e c n n ho on l ion tion ctio ectio s recti rect rrec orre orr Cor Cor Co d C C e

r n tion. b

s pe a s struc ng is is hi ro hi con ni r h r h r T r p er T mea he T e he The he th urt as urt urt urt e fur f hr f f f h r p

r er t er er n we we w ow ow d e Po Po Po P P n iv

a g e

e e se as s as s as s s ra s s r as e hr a hr a a h a t ph h do p h p h es h p h i

rti es pa do

ot s ion s n es n es e truct oe i o o do cons d t la d d . n. o p on. ion. tion. y ction ve y uctio dy n ructi dy truct dy struc d stru r a ad nstr a onst ea cons ea con ea con o h e co re c lr

lr alr alr al a a f

tra Th

n nsit e e I ion e h e a h t u

T e D

am er er d num s o ow ow on eric n st t p p ec al s) r s e; s er( i fi o n anc w t le dist po rection

y c cor ma re tri

e gi op ch h on di ea w e t s ities e b er ntinu vi ow disco e

p lu d mea n va d sureen n a we i ; tion on a i bet er ne rrec cuti

n ow zo co ose

p pr e

ion, a h st ript e d mu e resc tiv f de t h t p osi r as nee t ec p we hio e ue bj po n o b al o e to es v y h or s t s ari or t t i firf v ist a e h

dio h a pt e t

dri u nd ust nc vity. d eco m to a essi s r rogr o e a t p f ic rec t b tr cor me op ve. a di ati ed s pel,

eg cifi r e n e op n pe o h h est

s f t i t

he

n T n in in ai ai la la Pl Pl P P

de ovi

d pr n d d d n itio n n n n a trans rrectio s a a a

co on

egi r

on f isi n o v o

gi re s y y ry

ary er ar nar na in n ow h din di di ord p g or or or

i hi a

re a
d n a

tion. rrec g g g

ng co in in nin ni w an an ea ea on me me m m hi o

fas i o t cted

nne co y on b visi a

Figure on page 29 of the opinion

29ar Far

Ne wer po

IM n ic LA sio ntr C vi on nce mic si Co hal vi

pht O

ns Le M

ER

T

tion rrec co tion

rrec co

wer po er

ow p

be en ot ot n n n ee b n n io con sio Vis stru Vi

ed. re re ui qui eq e r r
d. y ny rue n a nst a co

e he n he on tion n h T i T recti T rrec ai T la Cor h Co pl p is

l mea is ary or h r er d in c d The th n ord m n purt ur n al a er a e hf f ctio ifoc se t as r ra er orre mult ra ar hr we se w c ph ocul p D o Po

ntra- EE P

i GR

A se

s t ra s as en an h a h l mpl p h er , i do w ry ng s ary e po na ani se in s at di me en ord o h or d l es t t an o

d

a n c” tion. ction. y

sitio , entri dy struc stru ad ran g. onc mic ea con con e “t ¢. “c hal lr alr

s pht a i y , “o e la Ls) ng on O a g, o (I ng, ch nin t ani I T re T d ea me n r h frac h on m g s” o e tive e sec n e en

ns” avi b l a gio h s am re a ., i d d o g., s es. g le io io fr ¢. ns e. n pt pt

i le act o s ric ric

ont t ant on en c nst si o v co er. vi t gi s e ON p at

n b UCTI resc gre

t le NSTR ript err rs e s CO ion, or fi b t

i s, r

e o po po mon ns f w we nts om le er r me c en seg n v a n i e gi t n f e la d h ture sio o iv p n t urva t ion vi g a s c yp rect t ic cor s r i t a t

t nte d o l o i ce n e,

a ey

a re re | gn ct ct

n ify ify avi har re aea ad in

g or e e n he n h h i T o ai T T a l pl ef r. p gl we eal in po ary orn s

d er din c d n nt or rm n on cal a e ce te a e ecti tifo as as corr mul r ular hr

ph a-oc p

intr T’S

UR

t. CO ns n nt e oi pla l p m er , i y ow ry ng s ar p na ani se din at rdi me d en or o h o n l t t a a ion tric”

nsit ., ncen ic “tra g “co alm

e. s hth

“op

i ay s), ge nl OL an g, o o (I ng, ch nin t ani d mea me on g e s” sec n en

ns” avi b l gio h s am , re a . , i ro g. s ses g. f e. en ¢.

i l tact o n n con t sio o e vi t iv s e

g n t e b TION s e s l TRUC fir b it CONS

es, or mon ns f nts com le n me e seg n v n i e gi n f e la d h sio o iv p n t tion vi g a s rrec it co s r

t nte d i ce n e,

a ey

Text extracted from the official PDF and reflowed for reading. It is not a certified transcript — the PDF linked above is the authoritative document.

Analysis is coming soon.

A plain-English account of the issues, facts and holding, written by Patent Case Watch. The opinion itself — its full text, its PDF and everything else on this page — stays free to read for everyone, always.

Cite this opinion

Vision advancement LLC v. Johnson & Johnson Vision Care Inc, No. 2:05-cv-00455 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2007).

govinfo ID
USCOURTS-txed-2_05-cv-00455-0
Permalink
https://patentcasewatch.com/opinions/USCOURTS-txed-2_05-cv-00455-0

No reporter citation is shown because the official source does not supply one; none is inferred here. Check the opinion and a citator before relying on this form.