Patent opinions from the Eastern District of Texas and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

Weekly Digest
E.D. Tex.

02 Micro Int'l v. Sumida Corporation, et al, No. 2:03-cv-00007 (E.D. Tex. Feb. 14, 2007)

Claims Construed
Court
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division
Case No.
No. 2:03-cv-00007, Dkt. No. 299
Decided
February 14, 2007
Judge
John D. Love, M.J. — Tyler
Document
Order
Docket Entry
***FILED IN WRONG CASE. PLEASE IGNORE***MEMORANDUM OPINION and ORDER - the Court constures the identified claims and interprets the claim language in accordance with the rulings as set forth herein
Length
29 pages

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS

MARSHALL DIVISION

PRODUITS BERGER S.A. §

and LAMPE BERGER USA, INC. § §

Plaintiffs §

§ CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:06cv002

vs. § §

DAVID M. SCHEMENAUER and § THE MARSHALL GROUP, INC. § §

Defendants §

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Figure on page 1 of the opinion

The Court issues this claim construction opinion and order to construe terms that the parties

contend are either in dispute or otherwise require construction.

The plaintiffs, Produits Berger S.A. and Lampe Berger USA, Inc. (“Plaintiffs”), claim that

defendants David M. Schemenauer and The Marshall Group, Inc. (“Defendants”) infringe six claims

in the patent-in-suit, U.S. Patent No. 6,537,061 (“the ‘061 patent”).

For the reasons set forth below, the Court construes the identified claims in accordance with

the rulings made in this opinion.

The Patent-In-Suit

The abstract describes an invention concerning a catalytic combustion afterburner made of

material, comprising in its lower part a substantially axial cavity for receiving a taper porous

convey to the burner a combustible liquid, and in its upper part an annular peripheral designed to

zone bearing a catalyst and enclosing a central zone without catalyst forming a vaporizing zone. The

in its upper part an open duct, communicating the cavity upper part with the afterburner comprises

outside air.

Figure on page 2 of the opinion

2Applicable Law

“It is a ‘bedrock principle’ of patent law that ‘the claims of a patent define the invention to

which the patentee is entitled the right to exclude.” Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 1303, 1312

(Fed. Cir. 2005) (en banc) (quoting Innova/Pure Water Inc. v. Safari Water Filtration Sys., Inc., 381

F.3d 1111, 1115 (Fed. Cir. 2004)). In claim construction, courts examine the patent’s intrinsic

evidence to define the patented invention’s scope. See id.; C.R. Bard, Inc, v. U.S. Surgical Corp.,

388 F.3d 858, 861 (Fed. Cir. 2004); Bell Atl. Network Servs., Inc. v. Covad Communications Group,

Inc., 262 F.3d 1258, 1267 (Fed. Cir. 2001). This intrinsic evidence includes the claims themselves,

the specification, and the prosecution history. See Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1314; CR. Bard, Inc., 388

F.3d at 861. Courts give claim terms their ordinary and accustomed meaning as understood by one

skill in the art at the time of the invention in the context of the entire patent. Phillips, of ordinary

415 F.3d at 1312-13; Alloc, Inc. v. Int’l Trade Comm’n, 342 F.3d 1361, 1368 (Fed. Cir. 2003).

The claims themselves provide substantial guidance in determining the meaning of particular

415 F.3d at 1314. First, a term’s context in the asserted claim can be very claim terms. Phillips,

instructive. Jd. Other asserted or unasserted claims can also aid in determining the claim’s meaning

typically used consistently throughout the patent. Id. Differences among because claim terms are

the claim terms can also assist in understanding a term’s meaning. Jd. For example, when a .

dependent claim adds a limitation to an independent claim, it is presumed that the independent claim

does not include the limitation. /d. at 1314-15.

Claims “must be read in view of the specification, of which they are a part.” Jd. (quoting

Instruments, Inc., 52 F.3d 967, 978 (Fed. Cir. 1995)). “[T]he specification Markman v. Westview

highly relevant to the claim construction analysis. Usually, it is dispositive; itis the single ‘is always

Figure on page 3 of the opinion

3best guide to the meaning of a disputed term.”” Id. (quoting Vitronics Corp. v. Conceptronic, Inc.,

90 F.3d 1576, 1582 (Fed. Cir. 1996)); Teleflex, Inc. v. Ficosa N. Am. Corp., 299 F.3d 1313, 1325

(Fed. Cir. 2002). This is true because a patentee may define his own terms, give a claim term a

different meaning than the term would otherwise possess, or disclaim or disavow the claim scope.

1316. In these situations, the inventor’s lexicography governs. Jd. Also, the Phillips, 415 F.3d at

specification may resolve ambiguous claim terms “where the ordinary and accustomed meaning of

the words used in the claims lack sufficient clarity to permit the scope of the claim to be ascertained

Teleflex, Inc., 299 F.3d at 1325. But, “although the specification may aid from the words alone.”

the court in interpreting the meaning of disputed claim language, particular embodiments and

examples appearing in the specification will not generally be read into the claims.” Comark

Harris Corp., 156 F.3d 1182, 1187 (Fed. Cir. 1998); see also Phillips, 415 Communications, Inc. v.

F.3d at 1323. The prosecution history is another tool to supply the proper context for claim

patent applicant may also define a term in prosecuting the patent. Home construction because a

Lifescan, Inc., 381 F.3d 1352, 1356 (Fed. Cir. 2004) (“As in the case of the Diagnostics, Inc., v.

specification, a patent applicant may define a term in prosecuting a patent.”).

Although extrinsic evidence can be useful, it is “less significant than the intrinsic record in

determining ‘the legally operative meaning of claim language.”” Phillips, 415 F.3d at 1317 (quoting

Technical dictionaries and treatises may help a court understand C.R. Bard, Inc., 388 F.3d at 862).

the underlying technology and the manner in which one skilled in the art might use claim terms.

and treatises may provide definitions that are too broad or may not However, technical dictionaries

used in the patent. Jd. at 1318. Similarly, expert testimony may aid be indicative of how the term is

a court in understanding the underlying technology and determining the particular meaning ofa term4 in the pertinent field, but an expert’s conclusory, unsupported assertions as to a term’s definition are

Figure on page 4 of the opinion

entirely unhelpful to a court. Jd. Generally, extrinsic evidence is “less reliable than the patent and

its prosecution history in determining how to read claim terms.” Jd.

The Terms

The Court adopts the parties’ construction where agreed. The Court will construe the

remaining disputed terms which the parties agree require construction: (1) “With a wick to convey

a combustible liquid to the burner”; (2) the “Separated” Limitation; (3) “Annular Peripheral Zone”;

Open Channel”; (5) Claim 5; (6) Claim 7; (7) Claim 8; (8) Claim 12; (9) Claim 14 — the (4) “The

“Wick” Limitation; (10) Claim 14 —the “Annular Peripheral Zone”; and (11) Claim 14 — “Fixed into

the Neck of Said Flask” and “Resting on a Base.”

1. With a wick to convey a combustible liquid to the burner

The clause “with a wick to convey a combustible liquid to the burner” is found in phrase 4

of claim 1. There are two disputes associated with this phrase, namely: (1) whether the “liquid” is

of the claim; and (2) whether Defendant’s proposed language of “This term may arequired limitation

not be construed to encompass a wick that extends through the cavity to the upper surface of the

catalytic combustion burner” should be added as a negative limitation. The Court looks at each of

these in turn.

The Combustible Liquid

that the combustible liquid is not itself part of the claimed invention and Plaintiffs assert

contend that the present invention relates primarily to the configuration of the catalytic burner stone,

combustible liquid. Plaintiffs argue this is evident from the claim itself, which not in any way to the

merely calls for a wick “to convey” the liquid but does not require presence of the liquid itself,5 Further, according to Plaintiffs, it is clear from the specification that there is nothing new or unique

Figure on page 5 of the opinion

about the combustible liquid mixture in the context of the present invention.

Defendants, on the other hand, argue that the combustible liquid prominently referenced in

claim 1 must be construed as a required limitation on the claim. Defendants point to the prosecution

history, including a response to an Office Action by the Patent Office dated May 3, 2002, wherein

the Applicants for what became the ‘061 patent amended certain claims because of substantive

rejections based upon the prior art. See Doe. No. 58, Ex. 3, at PB0238. Specifically, Defendants cite

the Applicants’ statement that “claim 12 has been amended to further define features relating to the

combustible liquid penetrating into the pores of the burner . . .” as support that features relating to

the liquid comprised a patentable distinction over the cited prior art. Jd.

disagrees with Defendants that the Applicants distinguished their invention While the Court

based upon the combustible liquid, the Court does find that the combustible liquid comprises a

required limitation in claim 1. French Patent Publication FR 2 530 144 was applied by the examiner

patent which matured into the ‘061 patent. The examiner initially rejected during prosecution of the

claim 12 of the application, which became claim 1 of the ‘061 patent, on the basis that the invention

burner of FR 2 530 144 to incorporate the annular groove of EPO 0 277 875 was made to modify the

as the structure of the burner, including the annular cavity that serves to prevent encrustation of the

wick due to carbon particle build-up. Jd. at PB0252. In response to the office action, the Applicants

specifically claimed that the “catalytic combustion bumer as defined in amended claim 12” was

distinguished from the prior art “by the presence of at least one open channel located in the upper

part of the burner...” /d. at PB0238-39. Thus, in accordance with the Applicants’ position during

prosecution, the Court finds that the open channel catalytic combustion burner distinguished the6 invention over the apparatus disclosed in FR 2 530 144. Nevertheless, the fact that Applicants

Figure on page 6 of the opinion

amended claim 12 to further define “features relating to the combustible liquid penetrating into the

pores of the burner ” lends support to the idea that the liquid is a limitation.

Claim 1 of the ‘061 patent references the “combustible liquid” twice within phrase 4: (1) “a

convey a combustible liquid;” and (2) “said combustible liquid penetrating into the pores wick to

of said burner’s porous material...” ‘061 patent, claim 1, 5:37-39. While it is true, as Plaintiffs

argue, that there is nothing new or unique about the combustible liquid mixture in the context of the

present invention, it is also true that the claim language references the liquid and makes it clear that

the liquid performs some function, i.e., being conveyed by the wick and “penetrating” into the pores

of the stone. Jd. Further, even though the catalytic combustion burner can burn in the absence of

combustible liquid or when the burner burns the last quantities of combustible liquid remaining in

the flask, it is undeniable that the combustible liquid is an integral part of the invention, as the

invention will not work absent “said combustible liquid penetrating into the pores of said burner’s

porous material.”

the Court finds that the “liquid” referenced in claim 1 is itself part of the Accordingly,

claimed invention and is, therefore, a required limitation of the claim

The Wick Limitation

Defendants seek to add the limitation, “This term may not be construed to encompass a wick

that extends through the cavity to the upper surface of the catalytic combustion burner.” Plaintiffs

argue no portion of the patent or prosecution history supports such a limitation.

to the prosecution history and argue that the Applicants of the “061 patent Defendants point

disavowed a wick extending up and through the cavity of the burner. Defendants point to the same7 response to the office action referenced above and argue that the Applicants expressly distinguished

Figure on page 7 of the opinion

wicks, i.e., wicks that extended through the upper part of the cavity the positioning of the prior art

atmosphere. See Doc. No. 58, Ex. 3, at PB0240. According to and were in contact with the

Defendants, because the Applicants expressly disavowed via arguments submitted to the Patent

Office for purposes of establishing patentability over the prior art, Plaintiffs are now precluded from

asserting a claim construction without such a limitation.

In the response referenced above, the Applicants noted that “FR 2 530 144 discloses a

with a cavity filled by a wick which extends up to the upper catalytic combustion burner provided

part of this cavity and which is consequently in contact with the atmosphere.” Jd. (emphasis added).

The point made by the patentee was that, in FR 2 530 144, the wick extended to a point where it

However, the prior art did not solve the problem of wick blocked ingress of air to the cavity.

burning, noting that “the wick which is very close to the catalytic combustion zone will burn and —

particles.” Id. As a result, in the absence of oxygen, the char and carbonize and produce carbon

wick in close contact with the stone in the device of FR 2 530 144 would carbonize.

The patent-in-suit did not attempt to solve the problem of wick burning through the

contend. Rather, the novelty of the present invention is the positioning of the wicks, as Defendants

located in the upper part of the burner.” See Doc. No. 58, “presence of at least one open channel

Ex. 3, at PB0238-39. The present invention provides the open passage that permits air to enter into

the Applicants stated, the “presence of at least one open the cavity to avoid carbonization. As

channel is neither disclosed in, or suggested by, either EP 0 277 875 or FR 2 530 144.” Jd. at

PB0239.

The Court finds that the open channel provided the inventive step over the prior art, not the

Figure on page 8 of the opinion

8placement or positioning of the wick. Consequently, the Court will not construe the term as

requiring the negative limitation asserted by Defendants.

2. Separated

1 recites that the cavity of the catalytic burner comprises an upper The fifth clause of claim

part and opening at the lower end of the burner, the cavity “being separated from the upper surface

a wall.” Plaintiffs propose that the clause should be construed by its (10) of the burner (3, 30) by

plain and ordinary meaning, i.e., that “the cavity is separated from the upper surface by a wall.”

Defendants, on the other hand, propose an added limitation that “the cavity is completely separated

wall.” In addition, Defendants propose the limitation that from the burner’s upper surface by a

“ft]his term may not be construed to encompass a cavity that is only partially separated from the

burner’s upper surface by a partial wall.”

Defendants base their construction on the fact that, consistent with the doctrine of claim

differentiation, claim 1 literally requires “a wall,” while claim 13 only requires a structure which

part of the cavity.” Claim 13 (an unasserted claim) recites, “shuts off, at least in part, the upper

among other things, that “a central zone shuts off, at least in part, the upper part of the cavity.” See

‘061 patent, claim 13 (emphasis added). According to Defendants, the Applicants knew how to

shuts off the upper part of the cavity, as recited in claim 13. claim a “partial” wall, which, in part,

are used in claims 1 and 13, Defendants urge, there is Thus, because different words and phrases

presumed to be a difference between “wall,” as used in claim 1, and the “shuts off, at least in part”

language of claim 13, supporting a construction that the wall completely separates the cavity from

the burner’s upper surface.

communicates with the atmosphere by the presence Indeed, claim 1 requires that the cavity

Figure on page 9 of the opinion

933) being situated in the upper part (3b, 30b) of the burner (3, 30). of at least one open channel (8,

2 adds the limitation that the invention is characterized in that “‘said See ‘061 patent, 5:48-51. Claim

/d., 5:52-53. Claim 13, as cited by Defendants, requires the open channel (8) is substantially axial.”

channel communicating between the cavity and the atmosphere to extend radially. Jd., 6:38-43.

claims may appear different but have the same scope. This does not However, selected terms in two

of claim differentiation because it is the claims as a whole that are presumed to violate the doctrine

differ in scope, not merely selected terms of the respective claims. See Tandon Corp. v. U.S. Int ‘]

Trade Comm’n, 831 F.2d 1017, 1023 (Fed. Cir. 1987) (citations omitted). In other words, though

claims 1 and 13 may vary in scope, the term “wall” can have the same meaning.

As Defendants acknowledge, Fig. 2 of the specification shows that the annular groove 9

extends axially over a greater distance than the thickness of the wall separating the cavity 6 from the

upper surface 10 of the burner. ‘061 patent, 3:25-28. As illustrated in Fig. 2, the open passage 8 of

the invention passes through the wall that separates cavity 6 from upper surface 10. Thus,

wall must completely separate the upper surface from the cavity is Defendants’ assertion that the

contrary to the plain language of the patent.

prosecution history shows a complete separation is also not Defendants’ argument that the

persuasive. Defendants claim that claim 1, as originally filed with the USPTO, did not contain any

language which in any way referred to any structure which separated the cavity and the upper surface

of the bumer. Doc. No. 58, Ex. 3, at PB0333. Defendants argue that in order to make the claims

application, originally filed claim 1 was cancelled and “new “conform” with the specification and the

claim 12" was added, which added that “the upper surface was shut off from the cavity, at least in

rejection, the Applicants submitted “amended claim 12,” part.” Jd. at PB0270. In response to a

Figure on page 10 of the opinion

10required “a wall” separating the upper surface of the bumer from the cavity,” which which

Defendants assert is the same as claim 1 in the ‘061 patent. Defendants claim the progression of this

limitation in claim 1 of the ‘061 patent shows the Applicants have surrendered any coverage of a

partial wall. Defs.’ Br., at 19-20.

The Court disagrees with Defendants’ reliance on the prosecution history. In the response

to the office action dated May 3, 2002, the Applicants distinguished the present invention on the

basis of the presence of at least one open channel located in the upper part of the burner. Doc. No.

Nowhere in the response did the Applicants submit that the prior art was 58, Ex. 3, at PB0238-39.

presence of a full or partial wall. This does not amount to an express or distinguished by the

unequivocal disclaimer as Defendants suggest. Middleton, Inc. v. Minn, Mining & Mfg. Co., 311

F.3d 1384, 1388 (Fed. Cir. 2002). Because the Court concludes that the prosecution history does not

change the plain meaning of the term, the Court finds that no construction is necessary. As plainly

set forth in the claim, the Court construes the term separated to mean that the cavity is separated

from the upper surface by a wall and will add no further limitation.

3, Annular Peripheral Zone

The sixth clause of claim 1 recites “the burner (3, 30) having an annular peripheral zone (7)

carrying a catalyst.” Plaintiffs propose that the phrase needs no construction, that the burner has an

annular peripheral zone that includes a catalyst. Defendants assert that the construction be narrowed

to “an outer circular zone” which includes a catalyst.

Both parties appear to agree that the term periphery and, hence, the term “peripheral” means

“the perimeter of a circle or other closed curve; also: the perimeter of a polygon.” See Merriam-

at 1-2, Additionally, both parties submit the dictionary Webster Online, Doc. No. 58, Ex. 2,

Figure on page 11 of the opinion

11definition of “annular,” means “a thing in the form of a ring.” Jd. at 8. Defendants assert that

because “peripheral” has an ordinary meaning of the “perimeter” (of some shape) and “annular” has

an ordinary meaning of “ring,” logic would dictate that the term “annular peripheral” would have

an ordinary meaning of “outer circular.” To not construe the term as “circular,” Defendants argue,

is to ignore the word “annular.”

of the burner stone illustrated in the patent has a round or The exemplary embodiment

1:8-10; 3:1-5; Fig. 8; 5:6. The claim is not limited to such circular shape. See ‘061 patent; Fig. 2;

may include circular or round configurations, but are not a shape, however. Such structures

necessarily limited to such. Accordingly, the Court finds no basis for limiting the claims in such a

manner.

4, The Open Channel

recites that the invention is “characterized in that said upper The seventh clause of claim 1

part (24) of the cavity communicates with the atmosphere by the presence of at least one open

channel (8, 33), and said channel (8, 33) being situated in the upper part (3B, 30b) of the burner (3,

30).” The parties have agreed that this phrase should be construed to require “At least one open

channel is provided in the upper part of the burner so that the upper part of the cavity communicates

with the atmosphere through the open channel.”

The parties diverge, however, as Defendants seek to impose the limitation that “This term

may not be construed to encompass a cavity that is only partially separated from the burner’s upper

surface by a partial wall.” In other words, Defendants submit that the phrase must be limited in a

way where the cavity is “completely” separated from the upper part of the burner. Plaintiffs, on the

claim does not refer in any way to a “wall” and, thus, other hand, contend that this portion of the

1]

Figure on page 12 of the opinion

12provides no basis for asserting such a limitation.

Based upon the above analysis with respect to “wall” in phrase 5, the Court declines to add

the negative limitation proposed by Defendants that the claim requires that a wall completely

separate the upper surface from the cavity.

5. Claim 5

Claim 5 depends from claim 1 and includes all of the limitations of claim 1. Similar to

1 discussed above, this claim further recites that the invention comprises “a Phrase 6 from claim

substantially axial annular groove” which separates “the annular peripheral zone from the central

zone.” The parties’ dispute centers once more on the word “annular.” Plaintiffs argue that annular

has its ordinary meaning, referring to “a thing in the form of a ring.” Defendants assert, more

particularly, that claim 5 requires a circular groove.

There is nothing in the claim or the disclosure of the patent that indicates that the annular

As discussed with regard to phrase 6 from claim 1, although the exemplary groove must be circular.

or circular, see Fig. 2; 1:8-10; 3:1-5; Fig. 8; 5:6, itis inappropriate to limit the embodiment is round

limitation found, not in the claim, but only in the specification or drawing, or claim by imposing a

only in a preferred embodiment. See Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 103, 1320 (Fed. Cir. 2005),

Accordingly, the Court finds no basis for limiting the claim.

6. Claim 7 - “to contain”

from claim 1 and adds to the invention a catalytic combustion flask “to Claim 7 depends

contain” a combustible liquid. Plaintiffs argue that the present invention, as recited in claim 1, is

a catalytic combustion burner and that claim 7 adds a flask designed to hold the catalytic combustion

burner, the flask being present “to contain a combustible liquid.” However, Plaintiffs contend that13 the combustible liquid is not itself a part of the present invention. Defendants, on the other hand,

Figure on page 13 of the opinion

propose that claim 7 should be construed to require a flask containing a combustible liquid.

all of the limitations of claim 1, the Court finds that the Because this claim includes

of this claim as well. Further, the ordinary language “combustible liquid” is a required limitation

of the claim itself requires “a wick (4) dipping into said liquid. . . See “O61 patent, claim 7. As

Defendants posit, if the liquid is not there, how can the wick be “dipping” into the liquid? The claim

dip;” the claim clearly states “a wick dipping into said liquid.” language not only states “a wick (4) to

Id. This additional language demonstrating the active tense of the verb “dipping” into the liquid

further supports Defendants’ position that the liquid is part of the claim.

Thus, as it did in claim 1, the Court finds that the “liquid” referenced in claim 7 is itself part

of the claimed invention and is, therefore, a required limitation of the claim

7. Claim 8

Claim 8 further limits claim 7 by reciting that the burner has “a peripheral shoulder”

smaller diameter lower part. Plaintiffs assert that the separating a large diameter upper part from a

“neripheral” has its ordinary meaning, referring to the external boundary area of a surface or body.

that claim 8 must be limited to a combustion burner Defendants, as in previous arguments, propose

which includes a circular shoulder. Defendants advance the same argument with respect to claim

8 that they asserted as to claims 1 and 5, that “peripheral” means “the perimeter of a circle or other

Further, Defendants note that the claim twice closed curve; also: the perimeter of a polygon.”

identifies that the additional structure has a “diameter.” See ‘061 patent, 3:15-17. According to

Defendants, the ordinary meaning of “diameter” refers to the diameter of a circle and, because

“peripheral” means the perimeter of a circle, it logically flows that a proper construction of14 “yeripheral shoulder” would be a “circular shoulder.”

Figure on page 14 of the opinion

es “diameter” as “a chord passing through the The Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary defin

line through the center of an object,” without figure or body,” and “the length ofa straight

center of a

limiting such figure to a circle. As the Court has previously opined, the claim is not limited to a

circular shape as demonstrated in the exemplary embodiment. See Figs. 2, 8; 3:44-46; 5:13-round or

15. The shoulder may include circular or round configurations, but the Court finds no basis for

limiting the claim only to such.

8. Claim 12

Claim 12 depends from claim 7 and adds the further limitation “with the burner resting on

a base fixed into the neck of said flask.” Two terms within claim 12 are disputed: “fixed” and

“resting on.”

Fixed

fixed or ‘fitted’ into the neck of the flask.” propose a construction that the base “‘is

Plaintiffs

Plaintiffs note this interpretation is directly supported by the language of the specification and its use

of the word “fitted.” See ‘061 patent, 3:66-67.

Defendants seek a stricter construction that the base be “securely fastened” into the neck of

the flask. Defendants note that the word “fixed” only appears in claims 12 and 14 and nowhere else

cannot provide any guidance as to any in the patent. Thus, Defendants argue, the specification

particular meaning intended for the term. Defendants then point to the ordinary meaning of the word

“fix” or “fixed” to supply the necessary construction: “to make firm, stable or stationary” or “to give

a permanent or final form to.” Merriam-Webster Online, Doc. 58, Ex. 2, at 12-13. Thus, Defendants

submit, based upon the ordinary meaning of the term “fixed,” the term should be construed as

Figure on page 15 of the opinion

15to be “securely fastened” to the neck.

requiring the base

The specification clearly recites that the base be “fitted” inside the neck of said flask. See

specification suggests that the base “can” be crimped around an annular ‘061 patent, 3:67. The

enlargement of the neck. Jd., 4:2. While it may be possible that the invention may allow for a base

element that is securely fastened into the neck of the flask, if it is crimped around the neck as

described above, it is not a requirement of the invention, and is certainly not required in the recitation

of claim 12.

Resting On

” the base. Plaintiffs submit that this recites that the burner is “resting on

Claim 12 also

requires only that the burner be sitting upon or supported by the base. Defendants propose that the

positioned in direct contact with the claim should be construed to require that the burner must be

base.

The ordinary meaning of “on” includes a definition of “used as a function word to indicate

See Merriam-Webster OnLine, Doc. position in contact with and supported by the top surface of.”

nd to support Defendant’s position. No. 58, Ex.2, at 5. Reading this definition, alone, would te

buted to “on” include “used as a function word to indicate position However, other definitions attri

and “used as a fenction word to indicate a source of attachment or in close proximity with,”

the “in contact with” language on which Defendants rely. Jd. (emphasis support,” and do not require

added).

of the claim states that the burner must be “resting on” the base, not “in The plain language

contact” with the base, as Defendant suggests. Further, each embodiment of the invention disclosed

burner (Fig. 2) held in a support (Fig. 3). The support and the burner in the ‘061 patent includes a

Figure on page 16 of the opinion

16are placed within the base (Fig. 4) of a flask. The patent discloses that the burner is resting on the

base because it is supported by the base. To require a construction that the burner be in contact with

the base is unsupported and inconsistent with the disclosure of the patent.

9, Claim 14 - The “Wick” Limitation

The third clause of independent claim 14 recites that the burner of the invention has “in its

part a substantially axial cavity (6) with said wick (4) to convey said combustible liquid (2) lower

to the burner.” The parties agree that this clause should be construed to mean that “The lower part

of the burner has a cavity that extends substantially axially of the burner and which includes the wick

for conveying the combustible liquid to the burner.”

Defendants propose the additional limitation, As they did with regard to phrase 4 of claim 1,

that extends all the way through the cavity.” “This term may not be construed to encompass a wick

However, for the reasons expressed in the section relating to claim 1, the Court declines to construe

the term as requiring the negative limitation asserted by Defendants.

10. Claim 14 - The “Annular Peripheral Zone”

clause of claim 14 discloses “an annular respect to phrase 4 of claim 1, the fourth

As with

(7) carrying a catalyst.” Plaintiffs again assert that the term “peripheral” has its peripheral zone

ofa surface or body which may be circular, ordinary meaning, referring to an external boundary area

phrase should be construed as “an outer polygonal, or some other shape. Defendants assert this

circular zone.”

Defendants attempt to improperly read into The Court agrees, as discussed previously, that

the claim a limitation from the specification. See ‘061 patent; Fig. 2; 1 :8-10; 3:1-5; Fig. 8; 5:6. The

to the exemplary embodiment, however, and the Court will not limit its claims are not limited

Figure on page 17 of the opinion

17construction to such.

11. Claim 14 - Fixed into the Neck of Said Flask and Resting on a Base

As with respect to claim 12, the parties dispute that this clause should be limited to a base

that is “securely fastened” to the flask and a burner that is positioned “in contact with” the base.

that the terms should be construed to require the burner be directly on the Defendants first argue

base. Further, Defendants urge a limitation that the term “not be construed to encompass a burner

which is positioned in contact with a support and the support is positioned in contact with a base.”

For the reasons discussed previously, the Court finds only that the burner should be resting

direct contact with the base, as Defendants propose. Contrary to Defendants’ on the base, not in

position, the claim requires only that the burner be supported by the base.

Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, the Court interprets the claim language in this case in the manner

set forth above. For ease of reference, the Court’s claim interpretations are set forth in a table

attached to this opinion.

So ORDERED and SIGNED this 14th day of February, 2007.

febP Fre UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE

Figure on page 18 of the opinion

18Case 2:03 cv-00007-TJIW oTDocument 299 Filed 02/14/07 Page 18 of 29 PagelD #:

AT ‘ H= QO

“ ey Sp JO op © A

B p eo Us UI nu >

u }x9 NG p}

s UO s ou 9 sT O n HsN p l qu

oio quy e 4 snq y } d ios e d ) uios9 sn ie ‘IO d d oio d UI p P 4 d NG oy o} JO } sul er Oa UW M 0 jen O o eda NOLL lIp OTI J O W ou s ONA SNGU ad J ] ) OM ad Y y LSN IOD Jo d oM 9 SNQ } t ) OD d n o O J Y wios od

dn y oW 8 p B d Y } J m n 8 ) ng o J U y
yAD b o NQ e J J SA ] s II 3
    • o B O UO M

UT D J a S 4 YII o ui ur }

u e J M ng us S u e e q u do

sp Oe st e J T e NA x a s O s S. u TE p S U e yqu LHN W l }e Zu u uU ON snq yJs i O T d s is e Ye snq A uics ,n j A A oD eI udi UTU u0S P e w o W s W

O e mo NI LA A e p I IT ‘[R y o ] V0 R y u Av A LIo A u S s ‘ye D d o Te yeu ‘ }I e } 1jA Lo }e L so AR ]e aj 9 yeu OJo v O }V “a qe 4 r

uI Jo yin YO 9 w d ro u ng ui s S I inp eo ) u e I

ng u M gin in O S o b g M T O Y i O L je y o O p ] o , Y L y U Y

] , U T u , V t . e ,

Y B

‘so

J uSUT on u yinLU Ay n sIUL ey Sp “AD g ‘je ID eo Uls U

Bay } )x IN

eu U o G

l OTIS O NQUp

IOS re

} d P

S}O

NO OI UOT Jo

W ITLO IP sNq s d IV NYUE UIO ad dn o I 'ID SNOD S d JO Y n y WI }

} NG

sn oio W J d U O

e IY

ud ‘p IM

u

u e s s

S Stje t T AT x

e} SIa UOT e

eO ut M snq

Ga U s sti O uIO aua TE e e du ] JO S DV D v y roo M

s j OT A u

1y o jt e AT A
eye R 9 so
s wi B S p ng u
ST ew oy U O p B e LL u , Y e

| 3 V

e y

,

YOA 9

J I}L Y o aTq o MAB } y B usn B O } qur ur “J Ja os yex Ou u J a ou IN in O SO q od G g W PN 9

IOU B 4 o ! } p

eys s 9 u u qn no sse4 e s W w Jo dur IV'TO ], d oous ) JO D on 9 o p p NO Ay q Y UO Y u IBS oye LLO ey S s YSN } e 9 re NAL ze Jo Nov quI MOI da SNO 9 up O yz 0s T s D ini JO I] in A ‘S Joy gn s }I SIN V b J U UT z AR VON AN e A y o suI Y ed O ATA B Jo IL

DA Ng UO a AB 9 da D jq U SO ed T } dO s eo Jo ud o u[qu 0sp Ja dd

y oyssnq }u d n O A } ngquto szx d A L Aja W uios o n } J], j}a A s W po IA e ;du RD ns R ros 0 "‘T d suo o O

eLo } o T S 0) o }e Aje ur y ul IE ua“J } } O u dOU p a a e oIN rn d y G YOb 4 S
O y j o T } O U U I T U s T, yu ], ey) T, e 0 y

e }

|

[S JO o sun 9 MO y yo ed “ -9 T } UO O r ou S NEU ya 8 ad T-IQUI } S s " L p OD y sn O I i W

J o n e W YO l O io E d o IW I a d o y 'IO M s1q q 9 y D Qus O ] NO nqu } 9 “6 U 4 , LLOO ios ‘J S S }J } UALI au “ q a -L od SNOO in pi J u so S d

g n o ] u n po B bi P yy U J “J ye

y ln IQ e ou sed

    • o s IM In as ys g sSH SO W jJ S AL pN e o ou u LIN you d in “ ru IV G l g sd HS T ‘ °7 u o Od P a Z S e 0ud oU o ayq jq “ -0
NE y usn Jy ed [ S ]O } quro jo v 0 “
    • o s o 9 Jo AUs zi ‘UO o IAe o B TU BRy y 0 SAUI ‘TeLio S } s A } o yeu S t Ja sAu y r S J u J yy O } T ¢ ‘Law e o A IN 0d pr o ] P i yL y n -Z -9 ng A

b u “S 7 P RO s ty oo t O y dy q U p p T ], Ayut ] T, ue us d s

t

WOs su A a TJSno ‘e r DA p sa y f NQUio J AR UO re io e } U IODd s ¢ OM Y S ( s d s N ou ) O Z d u V yi [-B o le ns ) ( sn yJ q

Z oi }O w od ¢ p “ ) s Su oe j r (g od Isu qd er b o dn y(O du ( x ry ¢ p u e S b ios (Q e m ) N p IARAL ¢ 0 nbr S¢ u L u )Jo } y ut r

Jo¢m Y ‘ ua d o IM ¢ os d

SL l dnq] ( u,1 o N “ Ajj p ) lau u ‘ A ( ‘ ‘ ¢ en etq In ( e O ( IN SIQ (0 uej ) usn g 9 ¢ Q T yA 0 ) san qui Jo ye¢ s co w a7 ) ) ¢

ye € Y in qus O d p Jo O g nqu Su Su

e o uI M ioo ne A rsu wB pu Ng no yi dw p ‘¢ u s ( us av uo0 u “

v 9 d ‘ o s ¢ W p ye ps IV ) [et u “ ) La u ) ID ay O ye re

J eu 3 r ¢ p ur J ow ur ) A B r o IN a qt a e Ja ng g eyn a y s M Y d ( eo Y ) OT

9d(O e p p A p (4 r g re re

1 T) g us s J s 7)

  • * e 0 o

A ] u e e}

v

Figure on page 19 of the opinion

19Filed 02/14/07 Case 2:03-cv-00007-TJIW Document 299 Page 19 of 29 PagelD #:

$ ° oi A A

o) V Jej O o jJ AR nu au d ue U ue y Y 9u} i yo e

    • o o o ae Jo y

s L u0 z o uo 18d dd ) o or Y z 8 Y z n q jin I “Js ] ) s Y AT , M ey SU

wO IW S O 9

U UOss s 4 Y “ je O] Z dd ) IM IsA [ .jU ‘o [ n u le ere S uo eio u o J e }e yd S Z yd s ou J 9 uo iio d y IN O

d d o ) G 9 Jo s u0 d e z [e. saye dn y 1U u p orun O 99o e uiw0

U u y t d s SU oN } s B 0 ezii uo p Jo Z ode ‘ op uI & a Jou ra o T Ng jel spS y IN oi Y re oy uNne g d Ja o m du oUy e } dd y ed sap ns n } ny ie re Js ou n jn Spa e J

r e Jey u Yye ay o

YO U ue }so T DO y

w YM o B o p y y p e o A ] u o T d

, e y y q } V s }

i

®

eu j S oz Ja J S o AP y J ad z m NI no erj d I a e $ e OU US n dd

A Tr ! JE O J wn yje J oU ‘ N ou e A ®nse ING IN oy URYS d q d J}

ss J eI O edu aj JU Y s ioo no S o o us y 9 s ) vy “Is ] 4 ad9 ins O d A , } d1 se Te a n ) T

q n IO B y ye O ] IM

9 e TM u

JO I9 SU ‘9 U y U A 4 u jn L u0 l ‘Ia s e A

q ) e o B IO z p u d y W u q J u In o ) IA
    • o e p g o e9 A o W s Sp ze y soy Jo A e uNO ] ) eotu dd B o LI nuTu n U y y Ns o 0s s ou s O ou a s

0 oZ y U O Uo O U u t ] UO ezL Z O } Jo , Z od tJ a y uI ea o o y W pee p NG s pt ) H nmy o e y ap I9 su) yer y } J ta s } oo ed ns “‘ o se o

os vji IJe }SA Ie re O id J J a so [N T J [No J } o ui o ey eU II o ng Ay I eo YO D O

ta M 9

S vo 9u au p “Tes I, soddn s], 0z 0z pd W a} re T y e T y d

p S j

* uP H s S So 8 2IB u J 7- c eIO ja U t od ST ey o | y “O d Z nu y s l ‘A uL Jvn

ue o} e A p ay C L- oue ‘ uo y le o ed a § ° ued Ty OuZ su pu q d Yo e Uoz ooz 9 n e § m Y ® og Ie }ys S OT “\s y 4 [No 0 U

AT }, A II U “ } [ Y e}SU .jei xe O S to Sg 2OT oyd [d E do A LL O iie uia So Y dy U [ O 1Jg,, I xs o u n ] @] “is ej } ‘ eo) O S r Y a u Ay[eUS suye “S Y M m e e}oy0 ozro ur ] I A y eOdu yd ue v U e

ed ied w ou a9 W F s A q s SUe l 0R r S d yV

su Od j.In U eyy - o } “ eoz Z s oo ‘ ] A

[eU TJO n T o so¢‘ y IA s [ y soyz vji g O }xa ) orun m UouoH JWO 9 O wUI0 s ‘J B uoez sa WIpp “J s s o ‘ io zuo d oquu o o s s ofo u de Jdn isn o un a uu o m[eB S a RIW o o y u 0

glo Spue U o l 0 r tJo yd no SD y t y ou

ues uny A B} }} INy d op s reU pog}

£ nyjiem re rp J p £ p ‘ oun y jnu “r s0 o jstao

7g r uu Yen u u o oT ‘oyru 7 “ “ vid J to e OU e ng a dn o o d MI9 o t B ey ¢ g ] dn“B x y y “S E “ a ] vo s 1

y3 y le s q ‘J ‘T ]1 y 9 e ] o o w q , 4 o o ae }y O A y Y d

e u

} A Y )

« —=

s —— = ~= ado = = — dnu B S sO p n ur utp- uo le ss a[ unY sz Y s A

vese o uM pu o }J y yqdia ms iesz . O q jsva p zed S y]

B U USOJVO u J TUNox o r t(q e} UIUIOay

B SU [ ‘ y D ds y (T e9 0(O } ou }o QUL‘o[e0p¢ J je y ( tA IOuo Jouo9oyo] E O J }‘T Q Su )] zyd eo B wo em ¢ lses d U J J ‘ T( O y o q“ p

‘ BU ¢€ z ¢ OZ ) pozu)

uo ) ajoR d ( ) p nez p IEYD os Qe ze u uo r J ed T ;nu e sde e ou pa Joue Aa sBwrn w zea) A u jB u g e ed In eO rae as q g JR qd d

( IU o

s /ysD sep y oR( )A]O yn ) ZA0 ey uuu A Ns e9 er to saPT ¢ d dA ou dn dnBOY

0z (O p M

    • o re o ‘ uu O (p s m ¢ U /)

}e ) ] ) B

Figure on page 20 of the opinion

20o u ]

Ys no m )

‘jeu uvY yo

slo yds ou ne

uo do

ua do M S e

Aj J T7 ye ou ‘

@ ns IN

ed g

o ssed y uioo } us 9 d

q re

Y er sn y om J d e ) O A U v U q }

u q

o A

A W

B o U y s

0

sr } t ayd sou ye ne UL pan u p

ID tjs } ay

‘j } uo eie ns ou o da yi ue s ov yo s

Ay Av

SI o U

],

dn ad s

u “S od I o T

$

a 6 y -9 } [

ZZ

y S -6 sn o 1 o ur 3y

‘ s E a

u

s1 “1 oyd 0 so 9 une

“

‘Jou ¢ ue £ yo 7

‘Jo

“ o S

1 y]

¢ g

(¢

JO

¢

“ (e o ¢ ‘g t] (Q 0 ) €

“ Jou U g g uL O YD l (

) “q ‘ po Jo ye ¢ ) uu nyi ) € eY s O “

u e d

p re s

S Jo g

u u dd un ad lo n 9 o p g s suo u

r }

m o

Figure on page 21 of the opinion

21_ SI <pagelD>

JO x

  • - spue |y ay

e xo

w y

[at} [ey Fo u e So so pN um S you b u r Jel o

  • o joje

uu

ey

o

suo ney ‘J uny A oU yjen IN

juv G

Jo jsqn

UT y s ep ny S

ua do

s y

SI ]

G p T,au a ue y J

} } o

— s —

y

  • - ) sr J-O x ] e

y

e

W y

|E}

BP u Spe

Ud }xo

SO so pny rm S pou b u r Jes o

  • o ye
su on “ ey Jou JoU ueAjje IN

yoyue G

z ysq

w oy ns e yn y y

T

9

y u Y

sm sd } y p o L_ ou

yre J ] o

0 U

} l S

SU pez IpI uajoI Os vsey oR o ( g

) ‘ye rx jo e uu eY o
ATy enu

JO eys UI qn NG s

‘p |re

s

U

TE

Y S

W y e

)

‘Z

Figure on page 22 of the opinion

22Case 2:03-cv-00007-TJIW Document 299 iQ led 02/14/07 Page 22 of 29 PagelD #:

    • o Q I

Ajj y Ay O gS>) >ej Sp [ etju } [ few JO e nu y W U { ey { ue JOW U ue o d}X @ sqn AV @ isqn IL } r O 9 s A s IP Je ) a

u J R ua Jau jn

j ad O D JO d j I uu ] Ay 9 So o J o SO J o W so o Jo Ng e , je 4 pnp oy pRp o I pnp Ja d t ou yi SU yy Mou yy d xe a } r ny ‘I r n r ny n U s % QU S j s (JS uo IN UOT uor A ) J ley o G EIIU 9 yey Te ‘Ou o UN u NT un u o yV o ] o p O T } 9 y e uo d z 9

} y} u T 4} z A0OI 0} r } O s S so

a y 9 A vy y y Y A y u } 4 yye y pin p e J J p e J ] LA p e } } ue oo s u y O O u y} o u y ysq d ta r ) 1 U r R w ) [ ns so r e s % 3 N e s J r e J fe ey l ey e[ O ey y O 1o U S J t J } S Ja t s so yd se

ojo u ojo yo e yer uo & so we jo da UT so We jo so ed d I | m Ip u mj eIp | mm Ip u | r s as eT b ue oq b ue % b aa oR S NU e ys UI az yo et 00 pI OL U
  • o w r YI S w O o w 18 ns II e Jo t i IM Y y r LO d s ) ey S } r 0 t] s ey I dn r o T e t } jo M y] y } y] a , y J , y J F O J y
  • o o ¥ o

,

  • o Je o Je a U Y uu O t uu u IY } ey } ey } IIM s Y o

}

J p ¥ J p O u O u JO

e , J

O “J e

9 US an a

Y 9M g y

[] JO [J %

B } q Ja B ] A

| JO | P

u UIV u A

  • o IP s RS

S U y d S W W d 0 Op N e o op r Y o } nf E y no e our ]S ) u ls } r ¥

O %

Y s

so a A } o 9 A O rin u T[E im 4 ljen Y

J b } YUI J b } uey }

  • o al SQns UI o al sqns

s NI

J y IM J J

  • o ] o O

UT suo W suo e nep ET yep yO Un J S ru y Ja o y Joy Joj

you ou ow IeI IeIp erp
J p Ja ay A y n % y yn y LA g

S RO s T I

yy p y , u

e

s T s I t

y ,

JE j

O N o Jon [e.jU Y S o 99 A } jje s0 rx

vy e

p ins S

J u AO O e OI ja S dd
a n [ y T } O
e & | Y Aj ‘IO
) jeu UI W y so eys NG Sop e Jo ye qn np y d red W s 9 ou e ) dn as IB r O [N 4

OII }

O sor mm 0 J ba } O

    • o s o 9 Y y u0 y ] } Z o
ds U suo J al J TE yey ou o O S UN y In Y ] e g ]

,

Ie sp

J s [N us so oy Ac IIIO yx RjI IN or < NS y s ‘o
S uO Y I Z M

], a

y }

Ajy eyu ‘ J ejs Jow Av S “T ou a qn i eu ‘ U E in s o ng r S -7 g y Ie pi0 U yu L Z

    • o ] in Y L aj uu } I ze C t} e d ad Yo W 8 I ey

r 0 B[N JO s yM o O U Je Jejn ) y 4 0 @ Are IIO s u s } J ydw s q ue yo y O ax o O o o o ul A } ds } s SU y S ] OO oi LL IS (Js s y IO } I A y J JO U e JO Te ] O I N U

s }e , IO I uo 9 sp s U T] y z us e I on “

yxe s y l O s ¢ so ov ey o ‘o yi JU ns y uo Y ns SWI ‘J ) z , o poq pu o Iep L Y uia n o Nu J e[ o U jer nu } o l o 0 E s oy U ‘S u y

oy diu y,, u } } ere ed B ) ru } da va U £ s s A wi po

S ye A0 T T ‘ yu 7 O U 01 ye J o a n Jo LU S 8 r od T d y dd . xe d B B ey “S n n u s r

Iy yq U } s ]

e y A y

A

9 8 B

B 4 ( B ( J w

} 9 9 ta au o U U Al[ 0 U sas dd in y 0 s ) 0 s ety ) ud n g } L e } B ues } L ur y J l y qn os AB

O s O NU Su POZ Ay p A SU pez A SU poZ UY Ip LIa [en u jt Ip ajyo Yjlt Ip Uajo ( ro jovIB uej re A Io RsIE }a IO RIV O oo YO ( sqn s eo so Yo ( vo .oe yo ( p v g s ioy R g ( 1

ten J 6o ) ) ov b-so ) O rx y s} ) J my je ) ) y [o en ou e eu uU b U Je 9A 0z 9 RY EY Ja O w UO O a o ya wi OI J Z
y U ng s S o o ] } oy y o yn u

y Ayj ) J j J eue (Q Jo O J9 o vo Jau ys je w W IN qns O p rsy [ in B IN G S ) u Su di eQ g G 0 u r lye se U

e rpu re d DD p Joj u Joy p Joy }Joj p Ae ey da ‘ ou sa au ‘ r ow ow “ i PN xo s |re rei m rer | e eI eIp | e UO s

p joq p s p Joy s ( E oz ( s Ie O jim 0 W y W N W s T n I b IT ¢ ¢ e] og P W e] V O e V O e O y W y W e

e r u “ 3 t y } ‘¢ y ° ) “ ° € ) ¢ p S ) )

Figure on page 23 of the opinion

23V QO A UIN p Y oO.©> © G [ u oO 9 ‘p [ ‘y w [ e Iy 4 in j re e @ M b s e d d U } U YO y e S UO L

OT B J HSN U

J SNG M Jo o GUI Jo za } SO o J ‘p UIO yi so Ja OD pr d B S pny o on m P S ny Jou rin yy no dn U pou yp Ay l IN ‘ b n ys so l ty ey br o ng | or g B 19 dd } s eo J y y su M n s 3 uo se y "Q o O e 1o neU l o o AO te ] y }e J } uy y o & W GR SOp aI O u y T Ny B

R] oU

0 SU t u J

L o e Jo I o } AR WO ye uI OJQ sfq Y o T}e AjeU p a ng WI p Uo usn v UIqu 1JoT u B y VIP u Tsn qui v po a OS osnq w e } p w e qu os B u t &ui0 i U je 3u T & ios sis s p re T ro ne W re el Su ap W oss s yd ied Jo d S rp no ] o iue as O yO

Sa ny SIJ i sip Ty d ula UN pn jou AT S 1 AT roy KIp | yjo r e} ur p eyL J um ur eO Jo dd ay O ou

uI ip lo a w IN o Ja y w N ol t r G y m ir G s } ey } o] s i e t o p m s y e 9 ], , d J J J o }

  • o s UL o

Nyo

t SOp

u e JO B ® J M

9 o O ‘y o ay O]

T1 o a y e0 4 SUI A[e B ‘p Y nA SA Su e ) 1 } UI ]L in } je pN ne d 3 YJU 9 b ye pOU re
O OD S ry o T do J p 1A U J pu s J O u Te S IA O e o e ]ed t RY s Ja S
p Y m Y ] u O [ o] v } [ e IY y e Io @ | M o e / d jowe u Ip JO
O ) w So U ‘ Y So ir o JO pn le p } JO um e y W s [ou ]S in U b s } IN o r & b IN o o G & dd Ja}
Y i G y l 1o n OW s Y P a pn eIp e o lo r s oy W SO y o o s o pNyoU u y rmb y J l J al
  • o S o
ur & syq U dd UO 9
UOT usn v 0 OT ip Tsn y w s snq quio B Isnq W s quI w 3 s r uo uIO s } uIO re uo CS e e TeT S S S ]o n e y ]o UI uI p E d ] pn o u o
jo us Jej re y ur iso s no ro Jo p o m y. Jo ) yy yn o s uI In y od NG y y s dn U s ou r T L t n y u y ], y } l ]

W “C pos H Jou sn s e] J I I osi w e d S D o Ng o “b O p e y ou U

p y b W AT d pI I s u u OTJL e] ns l J W ]qn re “ UIQ e9 O I snq y S O [s UIO [ jUu te uro r 9 D J ,Je et sUII {o [S U s e I -¢ -p a ro Li poq

OT d S “O 9 s Ja ydi a] uis p -¢ sNq S Y u T B ie m od un

uI0s T ‘( OI id -L s l o ,,) ‘SU o U a YM S d 1 v ] IT r

) s IA ip SO Ja eO

Te S PN Ja Jo T[e W o jo y AM J IO pn dd u B y s u ed oW UL o n s } o a 8 ] in ‘ ys x u u] 0 4e “6 & g ] AJ JO }

} d p S OA & e JO -L SO W M a v S s Y So S pN I eIO 9 T uI o Y u OU R I W 1 v ‘o pr i o y * ty L D ) al I s de oo ‘u u o u O e Y e y ‘ oe yo on u T e y s g ry ua n P AT

e m au ‘J U W SA A A v ) t 0 UOS O RO oKN JO T IL 0 J Nq O SNqu U eIO UI } ATe o ot Su } uIO ° ‘ ICS IN je su I PI A |d y 9 Ay TU v D ‘p 75 G ro yer “ O Al ur us

ey Te B in Z - U ud ed Jo Ioj Sep ax ye eo yI p e b 0 ua as yo our UL un “ o d

OS sa ou r 8 I d w er U oq A re

pn st ] * “ eIp p AJ g p pn yjo so [0 J p J OI o os ur p Su 9 oy a o g 9 f r ] yIN ylo g pr ae y e

Y IO n y “ l

s br S1 S p “ ey } y q s e a S y o o ] * ‘ y I] h u Z L ], , d J S 1 t y V S y} } T P O }t 0

I

¢ s

p t

a y in ) )

UO u O b ¢[ NSN IM y S quI } ‘" Jo uy ‘e Od u eie
0 in da ¢ g s ) B ( }

Z

) oN B p SU Us UIE S A r IPI peu JM Te e q OD eoy OD p t }e Y s a g [d N dJ i B 9 I ut n le B
n M Sum Ul t b ( a o } ry ¢ r s p q B } y
) lo o 0 ] ed Jo y yu A raydui mo Y ( r (je y s O Q yy & 1V R ta j AT oy E s Y eIV 0 qus VO m [ O O nqu 0 T|sn Su } ios } qu r yi

ICS “ dd Ys )

¢ ip ey J o Joy

“ po y “ py our

us ) no eip ( J is / ys E 1 o op Jo ooe , vy GO ) u so UT ta (

rn Ip eT u

A y Su O B ‘(ROE V s oo V W e u

( (2) po ps ¢ Y ¢ ¢)

p yo nb ‘ O Q " orie di O 8 1 ) ziuia ad ( ( “
Figure on page 24 of the opinion

24Case 2:03-cv-00007-TJIW Document 299 3i ~ + £ _ Page 24 of 29 PagelD #:

Q

©G jio

SS OA 3 ® d PN T A[d
y ISU eI } pien e I JO eS MUs

P[N MO

oyY U P sp s s p OTIS J un pu uo NQU o O Je oum ‘Io ozx s IOD J [n p s u e eq oj qn er

In y } urm g SU pb

OTP y

    • o EWU y AT M p O N } O u Y Y e } i , [V J gu m s UO A[p y ony in a or yqu TIp J U yo rem p nq g y snqu pe O OYS dd uM u ep y tos “ NqU n op e J } Jo IOS s Bv yo wi SUIUoe } d n PUIsu y dn g Jo O y D]Xa}x s o s prn T) run Oo o OS
oy AT gnri rn O s e}e suo b OTj

O S at W

u a B n 4 Y s el} } } u a oy d y o

9 y r J 4 u , o be o F Y } y ) e sm O E 0

j o S

po s Y sd A s ‘y d e o o au e oU U Je y m oo q a IN ] tn 8 Y ] G [ p qn } euo D p u y Jo nI o ur Te S u ppe U AT e jn y J e y OP in S s E qn io O od N[ JO g } T y D y dd d OU J AT } n A[p ns I 9 e E s seM 4
S g UM p 6 } Sp OP u JUN sp 9 lo p s OW un 4 y uo W W L od 3 ‘IO k ‘o I IR s d p ins W oq u e] ]S u u m UIN n d } n 9
G B Jo s bi } J m ] O S a o o Y ‘u

Y s ] so u O on u Y } er t r } oe e o O n } m M 0 0 r Y J ba J ba Y ] s o l } } e J o J J 9 d so AT O o o u 4 sjqu pn pr U oy } snq y yo J WOT eMU OT ssu uio o ur O |SN M snq su o s 09 s m QUIO Op uic ot B y uo y S P s eyr U uU } N uo od Jo u at] oIsu Ip e lsu U W A d M J Jo s a} Ua a}x OT U rey ns Oy ap pt xO }xo e Ia T pi T rno no p S ] de

ys ys so u Jo s

yp os yy 9 IO in a ny y M y q O T } U p p ] u A

    • o u e N e q y } B

(o de “b ys b

so ul [S y T-

E1

v 8 yo ns “ ¢ J s

  • o ou
  • o yy

0 } p ° o g ‘ y] ° g 7 “

0

“ 9 ss 1q ]

jo “ u o

p

‘¢ y o O ‘9 ) od U ¢ dn y J } U s s ) 0 JO su eo o l UI r ] s } ( NG 9 u JO p WO Z q } azLa t ‘sp P IsU p g jov lem U S] ) je g s Ieyo ( uM d xe u uon e pu ¢ Op e J rpp J ( o}x p ( 0 O p e e e u O { ® i

oA O —— ) } n e ‘( a ¢ br ( O g IO ( y y 1 Su ) M Y (1 p UN 3 1 rp €e O IM OW Y ) u uno e wo ] Je Z R } un “ d [N ) )

l s ‘ “ dn G

    • o ( s n 3 ( “ ¢ O o 0 Jo 7 € ) ¢ W Im ayq pjn 1 d ( JB W OTN nsnq } oy ) )e ¢ sp TN O SLY uto s w rem O qn T}O sUOD s

uM t y Es SAD u Jou 1 op p “ ) AT e s ING us € pop o IOD op ) ) * us} o y jn o o xe P s u } A oys d g u U y }

dn a } oA } q s JO u U a
oy M n TI g U m O eT B (0 d p ( o ] O y y S I] s o ¢ J e e 2 y U u t y e u A ) y s y ]) y } } ]} q 1

y 1 a

Figure on page 25 of the opinion

25Case 2:034-c© 0 NM 00LOFVOTUNTUUIO W Document 299 Filed 02/14/07 Page 25 of 29 PagelD #:

UO D o ‘M C

0 NS © Q

} 1 NqU Y S ) A [ 0 IOS [ E d x T } d s } J

I ey B o j 8 O O U B M jid o l U y } UW y es y ‘ray j , s OYSN O J y ds o o e QUI SU o

So o od ou se T se o] O OS MU u pn JO d a rye si Oy q U p Y B TE pi ypo yy n p nb Y O Is I JUO n ur IN s lsu o Ny J Y U M D b

y & l s su U“H } l ry suo on IO

S ne} eyU SB t UNT s ly] J J B } ] OpN U e ypo b p O

Ut oye S A o s oTUN S R A y } e 9 TUUIO T oyq Y q d o p e s y S ‘q1 usn G p 9 1} y u u a }s ) 0 oyd qui u 4 AT ) 0 u } a1 so W oo

W e ) eIV n e y } un IT ro T O } re } e E] Y p wi e] yo o O s ad ng S S Y s Su Y O 1 e oa u S o sJ J e I[ se AT 0 lf uo so ryq BU / arO o q qe y R} ] o g rm v p u In ua y VO

“ b Jo ua ) bo JoW u a1 w s w x I ot o w mN y ir p NG s e y UT | s } ey o yo S e

s } ey Y po x o o I rp O t O L ty u u U y

  • o y, J O O J ], oy , L t Y U y o } ) o } }

,

S a t y U } OTS O Y

yio NQU TA OI dd IOD TB YM J p ns ILS S O u S TQu e Y snqu } ios [J

e d{ J

g O O SLOT

Y UNU ‘s JO Y

IWUO roy o s W S dso } ou opn a o un yo e y p e B :su ur ] } Is tsw

& ul Ys dw

O e os pp so I1} So J & rm AT pny b e}V pou J es O r s

    • o S e
    • o T v y u Uot

W snq w su } I uro Sul oye TL s uTe e yU IO yW Yy N] S OS se

ulj o y qe 0 u

Jo vu } y 9 Jou a } p yn Y IN in y } G Y b s s Y ST ry s t ey I U u y y M LL p

JO , Y

Aj po ain u J Y d oti O I as sod M
d S U 9 U I
] 4 L O op ] rs

ul

J p 3 I O u J [ BITU

e O “ O NUIU

Ss Y LOD

e

T a q e s YO

/ e o o

q u

s S u

U ou U }

so e mn sn g o ba ] Y s & } Su
    • o ljq
y 4S eu ‘a sar } RO e Joy m Y ] ds nb IM oun

J es e

    • o O a V y

I } 0

w su Je e ote J } s TUN p R y u O Y
po e S S s us E ur ey
s jse Y ua y oy y do ya ny

ys o

s e s y yy e , q o o

U y u

} }

I

O Ja (‘y a J uI J ua u U ng ow ‘S ye l L In V d

g Q

    • o S po 0 U QU u w O “ ,L ‘9 O ljq O od } p IS p S eu UI dn U b-a} Bq s } I¥ s A OF iy O ID TeI “1 Y U S YU 09-
s } 9 S Y OS 99 “Y S e 4 3 } o SP B ]j ) I Y I] } y 3 U SI }

L OT Y “

J } M S y ,] I SE O U e , M J -E y y o ¢
S O L } e a J ur y ) y ut p O U V u ) a ) ] ax O sd y Y o o q S aIN } yBOTU A J sOT
S J NUT T “ OR I OSI e o EAIOD ‘o U o yu JUO p ‘E SO J S} y oyd O “ se ow D y U O s so a Q eIM e T ol uy r ba y “
    • o e t r } 1 s a pr 09 y s isu t o eg t sa “ ou J lm ‘u “ a JO o nb O W f p se U ar o Y o q IN } R p “ G U y 10
    • o “ 9
    • o jo y I S
    • o Y y o sa ‘ a Iy ], y 1 A a t ] V y } q U } “

q T 6

J “ T

u O YS i on P d 9 s o S T p [O e U O 0 J J le } S

0 Y a au P s Y } l pisu } INng ex I po t S lj J B ) ( S zila U SU O SJLOM Z ¢ UIp jow ) IPI IMU 10 leyo ( S OD p y B UUIO ( ) oo ¢ U OB le e UO S

Ar R € O s y I er 1 Y } pI pid ) I SU Yo es M o I OS ry o s se NQUI m

} y y q J U js OTIS

    • o s } } O v ‘ala W b] “ d ed d yd m ( dn ] 0 l ] sou D y s 1 ye E p ) Su o}eO W Y poz UT r[ TUN B o iojo O

qe ( UILO ‘s U rse u D ioy u yo Y } J Y s s 1 ds Y J } 0 o O e J our Se U e oyU y e ) ye y] O } s Su eO y SU * s T ey ) oo

“ TE e S o e TQ 0 AT ] u g o }UO y U y y eu ON ( A y O / TI } s } “ o } W W SI Y q V W 1 y AR V T a Y V } IO ( R s se y 7 ] O e y o ( “ e 7 o “ U q o 0J L u u Z I u T p s y ¢ T } ) ] } p y quio o ) “ Yse ayqusn

Figure on page 26 of the opinion

26SU o IA y R } u. Y T

} o ‘p w y in p oNs u b aU nqu y sI ios so p J

aU IN Bu G id

di p
e[qu snq utos

s OA t Te Ie y y & 9 or or m yM . p lo y

v

Jau In o g y

u r

‘p

Su in id by

st di ] jAq p Tey eo

® p lo s}qu y snq uro

y s ou n

0 UOT snq

} uico . po v us isa p Su

ra ey

o y }

p

y in

  • o b r y

olA & p ye re ye Y s ® o I

M

p lo o y yu

( r O

u € 0 osn S } qui ur

ocs dd ‘¢ y p p ou ) sis ap

Jo un g

‘(

( Z

+ ) )
Figure on page 27 of the opinion
27

O “© S> U© © ©

2 e 3-cv-00007-TJIW Docu@mS L 2/14/07 Page 27 of 29 PagelD #: y J 2A y O g 3 J e o u 0eGe uo 1 ejn y} uz 12 z 8 uu s e 0iru e S ov

9 Y JO 0 a ae pU jin

O J d} s cr ) Ay S } } y xa y T y s , JU A

A er p e SU OZ jje W xe in IU rx

J Y b J yjeo ouL‘ouje e oA O y o y oIO0ro

M y du z J z yd

ed ue

Js d

w p r uIN & u e 9 e n [e e Jo d u g IJU dd A e } d s D Y n ‘I B yp s op 9 OA O

en 9 yqu luen UoQ A Mjje UI ues sn us ezZ yu NG S qn } quio “ o LIo q eis Jo s Jo SUo Jo s SAdva qns me u LAD uI a T oy in AT Ng dd EI p y g s IO n EO ay

op D o1 ere s

spu ny As da y

Jo} ou Terep rep 9 s } oxo r Ienu nu 4 sA uN 9uey u 0 q or e } 0i3 9

ue 4 a mv w y a o } y a o y p p y , u y y u u

} ) , eO e J

U o

POt S LI}S Y wo
O UOS o nez U } nd uo SA

Ay dea O 0

Ja } eq IS UO 0IS u 29 A Z In YS IeTE A g n ]NJE jjen oSA om IIO ue

upN y NS O ysq yjSu 9 y} U ns

Sp ! 4 e Ud } ] JE }XO Jo 9 YI NI oie

} M N Je]

a 0 9 N

W 9 OI

y} Alj } q or 4 B 9O e BU mA } J UO

rx IAD p V a Z e A m JO M noSO

JO YUO b J LU 9Uv

oD r U o IBD 0Z

y ]

e r Su

v r Ja

y] A y u yN e B a r 0 O [e s d U su e ] I]Uvpu A T sed du I s)

yp s uro e Je 0 Axa

Aeyu yqu ou U Aeys snq s Y D Lqnp uio [ O O q

JoSsu s ] JsTY mo e UI e oddeyM ay p ] J D n ] aye

    • o } , ie y sp \s da
Jo ‘Jo us AT os “A w uI jxa "A Jo eI Y yy in NG YI ui RO } yo er

& gO AB ng B ‘a ry xe

O M S S OU u0 m

I o O zZ

Us ] Z p p ],e , y u u

y 0 , e r

)

Jo uI p p ng 9 u u so«[ oSO e r eed YO

upn} e jinoy S U N }po o s di ov S “ S ul Y ia ‘S jN O PU Y ul S l 1 I 9} } s‘\s o J i ue 0 -§ X9J SU uoAy ou ej su [eU _ JUO O IAI uze oz nu l 19 UTIp o

AM e ye O ] ue }X POQ s OD 0 o U , Sp 9 ue py 0 y o U un} } A } y s} o } yj } s AT J l

er p e Y o1 y od p Sa xe r I ‘ B er d B ‘a o u J Y n J yyes M8 eu[e xe n d u l] o O b o ayd 0Zloy ey ]

ry y uo du g J s JY A ed S o x O

Jo UT d Q ,

W} t B UL UO u 9 ,AT 21 B w in IO Z e )e o T e e g S} UI YB H ‘ d d s UO Y pI }o s T Ay a Z O o“raO re e Ajen J a1q le Uo A MAy yu y Iue O us s ne jetu }in S Aysq p nqu zio q ey g u JO ‘J JBns } ios dea sq 0 o omS u so [B ns Ar n U o e d U ) ey y o d D pa 0 AT du u ] YO n o [ ye } Se ro oz (

I 1A e. red Upu xa ed C M Tre UAy s a LUno “A i sod Jo ‘ro e1m dsA ey s s y ag p wp e $ u u R9uu Te nu A oo joI o n tys ng in eYO Ye ue 00 ds s g os z B q g O I axay U

M yt IT o a } e] “B yS a y O 1 E y y o s a q Y y , Y e y ]

] ) Jy s y

B o

    • o v

JA Jej w

onM (4 nu o ATO YO 0 ue J O eJ] Je 0 O B U BO txe M } € jes ®

(p z0y y

Zu dis ( i Y

r ed O m I

) SuQ M

S ‘q rpu

A p ¢ s1)

}yje le p 8 xs t nu spm“ ) j ‘o

ejs rb(Q SU e B u

Uqns er SuI rx so “( o

UO s] ¢ tAD e vy O (O z Tsn w uQ zi ¢ SU quIOI eo ns ‘¢ pT o Y e ) )LL SUL IMA “ d 2 IOY A dA ¢ RY uoa7 AA] U d qus) p [et 9U OTe

nqu Jo ze u que 0 Zu ico d jnu e jsq Z Ode

Jo d ue ns ( J A

( u n 6 o 9 ng po Jo u

( yer )dd

) ed n /ys as Js

Jo )Xy es TAy uI v Ay eT Aco eNey NG iA0 eo I1d UDO

eo} s a O

p w y u0 re e z s d ( e o 9

y x u u p } u e } } ) r

Figure on page 28 of the opinion

28Case 2:03-cvSIouIng -0 007-TJIW Document 299 Filed 02/14/07 Page 28 of 29 PagelD #:

J ua y

A o Od re <pagelD>

So JL Je o d INy AR uu U Y} S ey y } S Vo r
V e S d Y Ja
“ Mo Idd Le y n d “Jo a } Jo
O O ui uu U ng }Jo RYy OZ U dd o } nA B

VI I

ua A¥ soyeA

u J d U O orun

O o wiu a ‘JO

t l 0s y U y IN
[ey p ar G IIUse ap oyd SDo p o rao sou q re y oid ne u
d s y u } uo ]er ‘jo sdot

x uu

ye vy pa

y U e o ye

so T y so 9

e d M ) y y dn s
O e a } TJy o y ]Z ] o y ,o oy , J

ss ] O t

J

yo e “TS OU Jo po

y INI d ye

‘Ir G d oo Fe jo n ] Od uU RY u

O a

odo

sys A Y 9 nod JL } 4 ysd oAB } n a O
y t s } Y J

IMa io

1

U y ] Jau

su Uad e uR o0o TYo y} Ydp z IIM [P e
y L e d j Xe sot yeorua

O nurU

to0s

41 s s J

[e U U ol ad eyd O ayd d UI lJO so n O A u un
PI nT e u A pog] a RS pr ‘je do

u js Ao uu

¥Q id j ey “T

t ] o o oU

  • o IN y y G
ose p } y9 a ]] 3 oe y , UT md y

}Y ) u

w

"B

L

Y

S

L

E -Z7

Z

[9 -¢ ‘ S

-1 sa

ul ] sa m y ‘g “ " fo ¢o “ Jo o f g

JJ

O d

a( u €

d9 Y toy

S d I qe U}sn ) ye M SU d ) Jo In d O u

y Ay o m s t u ‘ ng

J av ) (€ s Y o (ad } s So }€ ¢d a a yBOT S n

dd UNUA va ¢

y n WIOD T

(y q Q “

Up g “

) o or g a

l “u ayd ) 4 eu so 3 )a} po d uye 8j m zLo p ou y joRrs r ur jo J eyou0 Je Jyo uu o

z os o ey

    • o u

u

( s t(

tp ou O ye asa p p 4zy id oEur
[eS)) ye e rUBd nz E9] is

ua

qp ($ d p ‘ eu o o re “( de 7 s G
J )y ¢¢ e ] )
Figure on page 29 of the opinion
29L — 0} 3S Qla=f© _ Case 2:03-cv-00007-TJIW Document 299 Page 29 of 29 PagelD #:

A

p O ° P

  • o S U } } j . S9 o U

J \ ..

sv s

a a ut U y uoo } dopi U

I su M O Jo r UI

J NG

p O 1

  • o B xy y syeo
  • o s runu
  • o ‘ e o ru0‘o u 9S l Iu 9loy

e o} 0 dso

  • o q } un Y e

s ] o t , s aSu s

a eq jorjq e

s y ye y e y us q O “y Y

se }

o7 y a s U y uo o T U ], u

y O l

o u }

SSu UOljq eu

a

o q

jS O } Bd ]| } Y

Y IM

Se ]

s j

1ur Bua do

oyeo

S O runu e rU0S ‘q y Y oyd ) so
un e

a J se o q

Jo op

rs

a ut

Ojo Yy ],

O pon S A JU yjsu T Oa I os }p Y

OU P

  • o JO M on Y uJU B B Lsu

Po } OS oo ua jse Y s U y IM R

p t I u e yi0 2 Jo dd q

wm ns

a n

Y q g JOR JO 0 s U JUO RI eT T D S } ] j

Aj o oJa oINI pouon u quIN Is tiso g

d v o I

  • o A B y sN y ‘ BU ) UI } as T sse e dur U U

q oou

J s l p l “9

  • o u s S

p e p eq

W ou au Wt

S oT oT y

I9 tso so E

I yo S } d d } ou U yo

  • o J } dd am se ou n n o q in s be Y q ‘a r ]
U S s S M T e TU
  • o ] q ] u , , U

V y 0 O W }

O ye o }U y OIN u I “ } y SO[ l 9 e OSI O '‘a y P

Alse }

L ‘ q “

p aSju JUo B p[S

  • o Bo WO J h-yj q ‘W IIN O Ob lf baI “ “10
  • o JO 9-9

A R 9

S a } P sa y Oms}

ma

JO Ybar ‘S

} U e-

‘ 9 ee

A UT 4 s

p U q ] u

  • o sy O JatI I ( l] x ] n a‘o ‘yu g p se 0s

oy qq }ye “

S sod d so

J }S dn O ¢uT

  • o ow s U A y

1 e Jo re "

y w IjU Jo

s in OS o

y g

t o s o ou o y “ a J y t } p se OU } f q ING d19 ay p “J

a y W } o yy “Bo ye IM r

a )y o q y }a u J ]

v y q 1, ] sto fp

BU

I O 4 pQU IS } S leO AI U el s 0 L y 4

    • o d y ( U

js } 1 }

p yee ax p a ) iy r y)] e S U

s ur 4 jI

(O jqeua sefy M E UJ

J rB ( o

“ 9 p oy ¢ [ ozus eoru ) sjoee o nuU

) ( seyoy 09 ‘qro ¢ u yd J sou oW ) rye IN s ( G e 9 (6 J q yo 1

  • o 1 o

u ) )

op i su

v as 9 r B e 1

9 o q 04 m u y ‘) } O }

Text extracted from the official PDF and reflowed for reading. It is not a certified transcript — the PDF linked above is the authoritative document.

Analysis is coming soon.

A plain-English account of the issues, facts and holding, written by Patent Case Watch. The opinion itself — its full text, its PDF and everything else on this page — stays free to read for everyone, always.

Cite this opinion

02 Micro Int'l v. Sumida Corporation, et al, No. 2:03-cv-00007 (E.D. Tex. Feb. 14, 2007).

govinfo ID
USCOURTS-txed-2_03-cv-00007-1
Permalink
https://patentcasewatch.com/opinions/USCOURTS-txed-2_03-cv-00007-1

No reporter citation is shown because the official source does not supply one; none is inferred here. Check the opinion and a citator before relying on this form.